Picture Book List: 12 Books that (Wonderfully!) Break the Fourth Wall

See the source imageOne of the books we (quite literally) wore out in our family was The Monster at the End of this Book written by Jon Stone and illustrated by Michael Smolin. My kids simply loved how Grover “talked” to them from the pages, begging them not to keep reading because he was 100% sure that at the end of the book, there’d be a monster. Yikes! As a parent reading with my kids, I loved how when Grover asked my kids questions (like “Do you know that you are very strong?”), my kids always roared and flexed their little girl muscles in response. Fun for everyone!

For those who like fancy terms, we’re talking about a type of metafiction here, meaning a book that’s fully aware that it’s a book, which allows the author and/​or illustrator to play with the normal conventions of a book. (Here are some wise words and explanations about breaking the fourth wall from Romelle Broas’ blog.) When used in a picture book, breaking the fourth wall often results in a great read-​aloud experience since kids are invited to be part of the plot. Who doesn’t want to join in with a terrific story, right?

I went through my PB bookshelf the other day with the idea of organizing them not by title or author name, but by type of book. And what I found was this–I have a LOT of books that break the fourth wall.

So, here are a few OPB favorites, plus a couple of ones you might not yet know, but surely will come to love. Did I miss your favorite? If so, tell me in the comments. I’ll make sure to get a copy so I can add it to my Fourth Wall shelf.


Six Classic Fourth-Wall-Breakers

See the source imageThe Book with No Pictures by B.J. Novak

He was terrific as Ryan the Temp in The Office, but he’s proven to be equally amusing as a picture book writer, too. Wait until the adults have to say “BLORK” or “GLIBBITY GLOBBITY” or “BLURRF”! Fun, fun, fun.

 

The Day the Crayons Quit by Drew Daywalt

If you’ve ever felt that some crayons–like some people–don’t get their fair shake, then this book will prove satisfying. My fav is green, the real people-​pleaser of the entire box. You’ll never look at crayons the same way again!

 

See the source imageDon’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus! by Mo Willems

The fact that it’s a Caldecott Honor winner is reason enough to give it a shot. But kids LOVE being put in charge, and that’s what the bus driver does when he has to step out. And wow, that pigeon is willing to do or say anything to get his shot behind the wheel. Good, silly fun all around.

 

See the source imageHarold and the Purple Crayon by Crockett Johnson

This timeless classic–written 60+ years ago–still lands well with readers today. As Harold takes his oversized crayon through the woods and past dragons before returning to bed, we see just how wonderful one’s imagination can be.

 

See the source imagePress Here by Hervé Tullet

Kids who appreciate tactile interactions will love this book, which asks them to push buttons, shake the book, tilt it, and more. You might want to consider the board book version so you can be sure it’ll survive all the physical interactions. My nephew is wearing out his copy fast–it doesn’t sit for more than a day on his bookshelf before he’s enjoying it again.

 

See the source imageZ is for Moose by Kelly Bingham

Zebra wants the alphabet to be simple. A is for apple, etc., but Moose is far too excited to wait his turn. This comedy of errors is loads of fun that’s made all the better by Caldecott medalist Paul Zelinsky’s outrageous images.

 

Six Wall-​Busting Picture Books You Might Not Know
(But Definitely Should!)

See the source imageThis Book Is Magic by Ashley Evanson

If you like Tullet’s Press Here, then this book is a must-​read. Tap a hat to make a bunny appear. Utter the words to a spell to make a book–POOF–get bigger! Just watch out, though. Magic tricks don’t always end up the way one expects!

 

See the source imageThis Book Just Ate My Dog by Richard Byrne

Want to learn what the gutter of a book is? You will in Richard Byrne’s book., because this girl’s poor pooch disappears in the gutter—the gap between pages in the center. It’ll take far more than a hard tug on the leash to make things go right in this curious story.

 

See the source imageCan You Make a Scary Face? by Jan Thomas

This bossy little ladybug will keep readers having fun. The bold, cartoon style and wild, bright backdrops help make this a memorable, vivid reading experience. Wiggling, blowing, doing the chicken dance? There’s a lot of kid fun here.

Be warned, though–this is not a good book for quiet time. Kids will make a lot of noise.

 

See the source imageTap the Magic Tree by Christie Matheson

In this fine book, readers are asked to interact with a tree. Every page turn rewards that action, with the tree changing in some manner. While many fourth wall breakers are more about fun than anything else, this one invites contemplation and reflection.

 

See the source imageThe Panda Problem by Deborah Underwood (lllustrated by Hannah Marks)

We all know how stories work, right? So does the narrator in this story, only Panda isn’t playing along. What’s a narrator to do now?

Check out the OPB review of this title for more details.

 

See the source imageWolves by Emily Gravett

Rabbits shouldn’t believe what they read in fairy tales, and neither should you. This story is pro-​library and pro-​fun. And if it seems a bit too dark at times, there’s a bonus alternate ending for the sensitive reader.

 

Agent Interview: Alyssa Eisner Henkin (Trident Media Group)

See the source imageThis month’s Industry Insider interview is with literary agent Alyssa Eisner Henkin, Senior Vice President of the Trident Media Group. Her Twitter bio adds these two terrific bio facts: “Lemonade-​Maker and Literary Cheerleader.”

While that’s nearly enough useful bio material to set up a good interview, OPB underpromises and overdelivers, so I’ll also note that Alyssa loves the movie Steel Magnolias, the TV show Mad Men, and Beverly Cleary. Plus, like so many people with fine taste, she’s quite the fan of Anne of Green Gables and she adores Bollywood movies.

With that, let’s proceed to the interview!

Agency website: https://www.tridentmediagroup.com/agents/alyssa-eisner-henkin/

Twitter: https://twitter.com/AgentHenkin

Manuscript Wish List: http://www.manuscriptwishlist.com/mswl-post/alyssa-eisner-henkin/


RVC: Rumor has it that you were captured on video at age six, sharing your dream about having a particularly bookish future. 

AH: Yes, indeed. I remember also visiting NYC at the age of six and just feeling certain I would live and or work there one day.

RVC: Has it turned out to be all that your six-​year-​old self imagined?

AH: Yes. I’ve got to meet and see quite a few celebrities on the job and I’ve had my fair share of power lunches both in NY and in LA. But while it might have been the surface glitter of the publishing/​film world that seemed cool when I started, what I’ve come to enjoy most about my work are the quiet moments, usually at my home office (in PA!), discovering a brilliant new voice in the slush pile or having a good heart to heart with a current client.

RVC: While you clearly have a love for middle grade stories, what draws you to picture books? 

AH: I love humor, and biographies, and I adore a great rhyme à la Iggy Peck, Architect. I’m also a fan of picture books that do something totally different as in The Scrambled States of America.

RVC: What do picture books do more effectively than MG and YA?

See the source imageAH: They are concise and informative, so you can learn a lot in a picture book biography without needing to read 500 pages. I think a culmination in a picture book can be so gratifying too when done with relatively few words and the perfect image that just kind of says it all. I shared Wemberly Worried recently with my soon-​to-​be five-​year-​old son, and that moment when the two shy little kids in stripes meet is just so rewarding!

RVC: Let’s talk about your agency. It strikes me that Trident is more committed than some to securing foreign rights sales for your clients. Why is that part of your mission?

AH: Trident devotes a lot of resources to its full-​service foreign rights department. Many agencies use co-​agents in major markets so that their bestselling titles are competing with other agencies’ bestselling titles, so we are so fortunate to have a dedicated rights team that sells only Trident titles and attends 3 international books fairs every year. We’ve found that making foreign sales for our clients is great from a financial perspective because a foreign sale is like “found money.” The author does not need to do anything other than approve the deal and the jacket. The author does not pay for translation costs, but they are compensated for this book to exist in a whole other language/​territory.

Also, sometimes books that are moderately successful in the United States can be bestsellers abroad. We have even had clients create special editions just for certain markets if they have a huge following.

RVC: In other interviews, you’ve called yourself an entrepreneur. What does that mean to you, and how does that play out in your role as a literary agent?

AH: Early on in my career when I was still an editor, I realized that sitting in meetings all day and making decisions by committee was not how I wanted to spend my life. I also did not want to be typecast as doing just one kind of book. As an entrepreneurial agent, I get to have my hands and mind in as many projects as I can manage. I love the breadth and diversity of my list and the range of jobs that abound. On any given day, I can be advocating for my clients in myriad ways, from negotiating film rights, to going out on submission, to advocating for an author tour. I also like to approach individuals and brands that have not had books before, but who I think should be in the book business.

I also have a soft spot for sleeper books that exceed expectations and backlist for a long time! There’s nothing I love more than a scrappy story that defies and surpasses everyone’s expectations of what sells. Having a back-​end source of revenue is every entrepreneur’s dream!

RVC: More and more aspiring picture book writers read the OPB interviews, so let’s give them a hand here. Imagine a picture book writer who’s thinking of submitting to you. What are three picture books you’d love for them to read that might offer a good sense of the type of PB you appreciate/​prefer?

ASOR jacketAH: Rosie Revere, Engineer, A Splash of Red (by my client Jen Bryant), and The Day the Crayons Quit. I’m not usually one for really spare language…I like a rich and funny story, and if there’s a feminist empowerment or humor bent, then all the better!

RVC: And one more thing for those aspiring writers, please. What are your feelings about art notes from text-​only writers?

AH: I would try to be judicious and not include too many art notes since we want the text to stand on its own. That said, I think a few well-​chosen art notes can work.

This Is MY Room!: (No Tigers Allowed) by [Jacobson, Jennifer Richard]RVC: A month or so back saw the publication of This is MY Room! (No Tigers Allowed), a picture book by your client Jennifer Richard Jacobson. Please share your process of preparing a manuscript for submission. Are you super hands-​on? Editorial? More focused on marketing angles? Do you see early drafts or is what your clients send you a “final”?

AH: When a client has a new picture book manuscript, we usually do a few rounds of text revisions before I am ready to start creating the pitch letter and the list of editors who I plan to pitch. In the pitch letter, I always highlight what’s unique about this book and also WHERE I see it sitting in the market. Some books are more gift-​oriented and some are more school and library-​oriented with backlist potential. I know I’ve done my job well when I recognize bits of my pitch letter in the flap copy for the book when it gets published.

Once a book is sold to an editor, I don’t usually do much of the editorial work since I think it’s important not to have too many cooks in the kitchen. That said, I always read the revisions and weigh in on artists and jacket and title and, of course, the marketing. Since my job is to sell the next book and the one after that, I always like the current book to be so successful that it makes subsequent sales that much easier.

RVC: Since I run the creative writing program at Ringling College of Art and Design, I semi-​frequently get asked questions about elephants/​the circus/​clown college, all of which have as much to do with my college as bicycles do to fish. 

So, I have to ask—how many questions/​jokes/​comments do YOU hear about Trident sugarless gum and/​or that fifth dentist who just won’t cave?

AH: So cool about Ringing College! Believe it or not, I’ve never gotten a single remark about Trident gum, but I do remember those commercials quite vividly from my childhood! These days, Trident Media Group is also branding itself as TMG, so maybe other folks noted the gum thing? 😊

RVC: Okay. It’s time for … THE LIGHTNING ROUND! Zip-​zappy questions and electrifyingly quick answers, please. Ready?

AH: Ready!

RVC: If I were a character on Downton Abbey, I’d be …

AH: The Dowager, without a doubt!

RVC: #1 hot dog condiment?

AH: Mustard. Never ketchup!

RVC: Which deceased writer would you most love to have shadowed for a full workday?

AH: Edith Wharton.

RVC: What project—picture book or otherwise—are you most excited about right now?

AH: I hate to play favorites among clients, so I’m going to link into the wonderful array of books I have coming out this year on my web page. Short answer, excited about ALL OF THEM!

https://www.tridentmediagroup.com/agents/alyssa-eisner-henkin/

RVC: Best recent picture book with interactive family-​bonding potential baked right into its literary DNA?

See the source imageAH: This is MY Room!, Pirates Don’t Go to Kindergarten!, and Joan Proctor, Dragon Doctor, because we are a big history/​science-​loving family!

RVC: Three words that describe your agenting philosophy.

AH: Passion. Persist. Visionary.

RVC: Thanks so much, Alyssa! (And thanks as well to Alice, your on-​the-​ball assistant, for helping pull this all together.)

Educational Activities: The Ant Farm Escape by Heather Macht

See the source image

The Ant Farm Escape!
Author: Heather Macht
Illustrator: David Harrington
Pelican Press
17 January 2019
32 pages

Follow along through rhyming text as an ant colony is newly relocated to an ant farm and it’s time to break ground. They’re ready to build and (here’s a fun fact about worker ants), they’re all GIRLS!


Need some reviews of The Ant Farm Escape!?

Foreword

Goodreads

 

And for bonus #1, here’s the “story behind the story” of this book from Lynne Marie’s blog.

Here’s bonus #2, The Ant Farm Escape! book trailer.

And last but not least, here’s bonus #2: an interview with author Heather Macht (by Rhys Keller).


Educational Activities inspired by The Ant Escape! by Heather Macht:

  • Before Reading–From looking at the front and back cover: 
    • What do you already know about ants?
    • Where and when does this story seem to take place?
    • What kind of equipment do the ants have? Does any of it surprise you?
    • How many of the ants appear to be female?
  • After Reading–Now that you’ve read the story: 
    • Which of the ant facts surprise you the most?
    • Would you like your own ant farm? Why/​why not?
    • How would you describe the style of the pictures?
    • Go back and revisit the pictures in this book. Which of them is your favorite? Why?
  • Writing–Try your hand at creating your own ant story. Write what happens when the colony in this story leaves the ant farm and goes the nearby hill. Or tell the story of a single ant from this story or from your imagination. Who would have the most interesting story to share–a queen, a worker, or a whole group of ants?
  • Craft–With an adult’s help, try some of the following ant-​themed crafts: 
    • Ant Puppet–Easy enough for the smallest to create, fun enough for everyone. Comes with a song, too!
    • Egg Carton Ant Figure–Perfect for preschoolers.
    • 3D Paper Ant–Very easy craft–black construction paper, scissors, and a glue stick. That’s it!
    • Plastic Spoon Ant–Love DIY projects? Dig recycling? This video shows how to make a cool ant from a Styrofoam ball and a plastic spoon.
    • Ant Printable–Super easy, though it has a bit more cutting than other projects listed here.
  • Further Reading–Want more books that showcase the small-​but-​awesome world of ants? (Click on the book cover for more information on any of these titles!)

See the source image

See the source image

See the source image

See the source image

 

 

Author Interview: Marilyn Singer

This month’s Author Interview at Only Picture Books is with Marilyn Singer, the author of 90+ books for children and young adults. In addition to being an incredibly prolific author, she’s the host of the former AOL Children’s Writers Chat and currently co-​hosts the Poetry Blast at various conferences.

Need more Marilyn bio nuggets? Try these five facts:

  1. She LOVES swing dancing.
  2. She auditioned for Jeopardy but didn’t get selected–yet.
  3. She got to sing with a chorus for a track on the recording of the revival of the Broadway musical, Pippin.
  4. She’s lives with a cat named Benito and a poodle named Bizzy.
  5. She writes in so many different styles and genres—picture books, realistic novels, fantasy, mysteries, fairy tales, nonfiction, poetry, etc.—because it “keeps her from getting bored.”

Feel like you’ve got enough of a sense of things now to move straight to interview time? Let’s go!

Website: https://marilynsinger.net/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/WriterBabe


RVC: It’s my understanding that your love for language emerged at a very early age thanks to the efforts of your family. What specifically did they do?

MS: My Romanian grandmother, who lived with us, told me marvelous stories every night. My parents read to me a lot, especially fairy tales and poetry. They also sang to me popular songs of the day. I grew up appreciating great lyricists such as Cole Porter, Ira Gershwin, Lorenz Hart, and Johnny Mercer. So, my family really did teach me to love language.

RVC: Rumor has it that you were writing your own poems in elementary school. What did you like most about poetry back then?

MS: I think I liked the rhythm and musicality, particularly because I loved songs and singing. I also liked the emotion behind poetry and the fact that it could move me and other people and also make us laugh.

RVC: Despite all that, you didn’t consider writing as a career until a few years after college, right? Why not? What helped you make the move into the world of words? 

MS: Oh, I thought about writing as a career way back in elementary school—that, and having a dog kennel. 😉

But as I got older, my mom said that teaching was a stable career for a woman, and I decided she was probably right. So, I did become a high school English teacher, but I didn’t stay long in that career. I was rather rebellious and didn’t get along with the administration. When I quit teaching, I wasn’t sure what I wanted to do. My husband, Steve Aronson–head of the film department of the American Federation of Arts–got me jobs writing teaching guides and catalog copy about films and also filmstrips (remember those?). Then one day to my surprise, when I was sitting in the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, I started writing stories about insect characters I’d made up when I was eight. I read the stories to Steve, who was encouraging, and I joined the Bank Street Writers Lab, and the members were also positive. I submitted those and other stories and I was very lucky. I got a manuscript accepted after about six months.

Would that it were that easy since!

RVC: Tell us a bit more about that first book and what it meant to you.

MS: Well, as I said, I was most fortunate. My first book was The Dog Who Insisted He Wasn’t. Ann Durell at Dutton accepted it and my next two books as well. I imagined my own dogs talking and having particular ideas and traits about personhood, and I think the book grew out of that. Once it and my next books were published, I decided that maybe I WAS a writer. It’s not an easy profession, though. It has serious ups and downs—from acceptances and rejections to good sales and low ones to books still in print for decades to those going out of print after a year. Still, I get to make my own hours and work in my pjs if I want to, and that’s not bad!

RVC: What’s one thing that non-​poets don’t fully appreciate about poetry?

MS:  Hmm, I don’t know if they realize that good poetry is hard to write and that it doesn’t always have to rhyme. A lot of folks who dislike poetry think it’s abstruse, which may be true of some poems, but certainly not all. Some also think that there’s just one type of poetry, which isn’t true in the least. I believe that there’s a poem or a type of poetry for all readers to enjoy. But they may need help finding it, which is where teachers, parents, other relatives, and friends come in.

See the source imageRVC: Just the other day, I picked up Mirror Mirror: A Book of Reverso Poems in my weekly grab-​whatever-​catches-​my-​eye run at the public library. What made you think of creating a book like that?

MS: One day I was watching my cat sitting in an easy chair and a poem came into my head:

A cat                                       Incomplete:

without                                    A chair

a chair:                                    without

Incomplete.                             a cat.

I began to wonder if I could come up with more poems like that. I wrote a number of them on a variety of subjects, but quite a few were based on fairy tales. I showed them to an editor who suggested I do an entire collection based on fairy tales, and that’s how Mirror Mirror (Dial, 2010), with divine illustrations by Josée Masse, came about.

I originally called them up-​and-​down poems. It was my husband who came up with the word “reverso.” To write a reverso, I follow strict rules—when the lines are reversed, there are changes in just punctuation and capitalization, and the second half of the poem has to say something different from the first half. These poems are tricky to write. I have to be in a games-​playing head. Also, I have to write them on a computer, as opposed to a legal pad (which is how I write many of my poems) so that I can shift around the lines and see if they make sense.

RVC: You’ve got a host of animal-​related books out in 2019 and 2020—one on presidential pets, one on insects and spiders, one on animals that live in cities, and one on how animals eat. Did you write a lot of animal poems and they sort of fell into these categories, or do you come up with the title/​idea first and then create the poems?

MS: The theme came up first for each of those books. Then I started to write the poems. Two of those books, Bug Dipping, Bug Sipping (S&S, 2020) and Gulp, Gobble (S&S, 2019) are each really a single poem. Who Named Their Pony Macaroni? (Disney-​Hyperion, 2019) and Wild in the Streets (Quarto, 2019) are collections. I never feel that I have a collection in the works until I write a minimum of five to seven poems. And then I have to write a lot more to finish the collection.

RVC: When do the titles happen?

MS: The title almost always comes last, sometimes after much discussion with editors, marketing people, and friends.

RVC: So, you’re essentially a lifelong New Yorker. And what’s something most people don’t appreciate or understand about being a New Yorker?

MS: That’s an interesting question. I think a lot of people believe that New Yorkers are cold or hard when in fact people here are generally friendly and helpful. I’m a native New Yorker and I find I start conversations with folks anywhere and anytime. People here love to give directions and advice on things to see and do.  And they will help you if you are in trouble. I once tripped on the street and a stranger picked me up and held me until I said I was fine. We do tend to be in a hurry a lot of the time, though, and I know that when I’m trying to get to a Broadway theater, I get impatient with tourists taking selfies. 😉

RVC: How does your New York-​ness play into your writing?

MS: I think the energy here gives me energy to write, and I also think some of my work is inspired by the city—books such as City Lullaby and poems in Nine O’Clock Lullaby, On the Same Day in March, A Full Moon Is Rising, Every Month Is a New Year, and Wild in the Streets, just to name a few.

RVC: Of the many awards and honors you’ve received, which meant the most to you?

MS: I was thrilled to receive the 2015 National Council of Teachers of English (NCTE) Excellence in Poetry for Children Award because it was for the body of my work. I found out I’d won it at a birthday brunch for my husband, so we both got to celebrate that day.

RVC: Now it’s time to close things out with the Awesome Sauce, Mesmerizing, Life-​or-​Death-​Stakes* SPEED ROUND! (*life or death stakes not included!) Ready?

MS: As Neil deGrasse Tyson would say, “Let’s do this!”

RVC: Cake, cupcakes, or pie?

MS: Pie—or maybe tres leches cake.

RVC: Three careers you might’ve had if you never got into kidlit?

MS: Casting director. Zoo keeper. Cabaret singer.

RVC: So, you’re having a dinner party with three guests from the world of books. Living or dead, real or imaginary, what three characters would you invite?

MS: I’d invite Shakespeare, Lin-​Manuel Miranda, and Irene Pepperberg, who studies parrots. They’ve all written books/​plays, so do they count?

RVC: Of course! It’s your party, after all. Next question–which of your books is your secret favorite?

See the source imageMS: That’s a really hard question to answer. I’m fond of my first poetry collection, Turtle in July, and Mirror Mirror, too, since it was a surprise even to me! I also really like The First Few Friends, a YA novel set in the late 60s that bombed at the box office, as it were. I think it might’ve done better if it had been published today.

RVC: Most underappreciated yet awesome kidlit poet working today?

MS: All kidlit poets are underappreciated! Poetry is underappreciated! You’re not going to get me to name names. 😉

RVC: What would you like your literary epitaph to be?

MS: I came, I saw, I wrote about it.

RVC: Thanks so much, Marilyn!

 

 

 

Picture Book Review: We Are (Not) Friends by Anna Kang


We Are (Not) Friends
Author: Anna Kang
Illustrator: Christopher Weyant
Two Lions
1 April 2019
40 pages

This month’s PB review is by Ryan G. Van Cleave (#1 Friend at Only Picture Books) and Ringling College of Art and Design Illustration Professor (and OPB superfriend) John Herzog.

–Ryan’s Review of the Writing–

We Are (Not) Friends is the fourth book in the You Are (Not) Small series, and the same fuzzy pals we’ve come to know from the other titles are here again with a new problem. The two of them are engaged in a terrific playdate with a cool trunk of fun stuff, and suddenly a new (blue) pal arrives, asking: “Can I play with you?”

Big brown fuzzy pal: “Yes!”

Little purple fuzzy pal: “Well…”

See where this is going? Welcome to the world of playdate–and friendship–politics. So many of the fun things this new trio of “friends” wants to try are best suited for two, such as a dancing duet. What’s the left-​out fellow to do when the other two are having fun without them? Whether it’s playing at being dinosaur hunters or pretending to build a car, someone is on the outs each time.

The sparse text doesn’t get in the way of telling an important, vital story that showcases how friends–old and new–can get along if the idea of what friendship means is re-​examined and re-​imagined. Part of the fun, as well, is the delightful sound effects such as WHUMP, ERGG, OOPH, and BONK that dovetail with Weyant’s comedic visuals.

While I’m still a bit more taken by You Are (Not) Small, this latest book is a worthy addition to the series and will likely please many readers, big AND small alike. Adult readers, in particular, will appreciate the lesson on friendship and inclusion.

4.25 out of 5 pencils

 

–John’s Review of the Illustrations–

Friendship and empathy are at the heart of Anna Kang and Christopher Weyant’s endearing We Are (Not) Friends, which tells the story of three friends who each feel left out at some point or another during their playdate.

The story is simple, and the illustrations complement that simplicity well. Like the previous books in the series, this is very much a character study with minimal backgrounds and as-​needed props. Instead of showing the characters against grand vistas and views, the illustrations are hyper-​focused on these “fuzzy friends” trying to navigate the perils that can come with new friends.

An aspect of the characters that really stands out to me is their expressions. As an illustrator who admires and strives for simplicity, Weyant has achieved moments of humor, sadness, and depth with a mere handful of brush strokes. For me, looking at the effectiveness of these expressions is like watching Usain Bolt run the 100-​meter dash or watching Gene Kelly dance while wearing roller skates. Weyant makes it look so darn easy when, in reality, nothing could be further from the truth. Simple is hard, and anyone who says differently is selling something.

My one nit-​pick with the illustrations might be viewed as charming to others, but not to me. It doesn’t detract from the overall experience of the book, but I have to say… It drives me nuts that I don’t exactly know the species of these “fuzzy friends.” One looks like a bear, another looks like a kangaroo, and another looks like a gopher. But it’s never exactly clear WHAT these animals are supposed to be. That’s something I appreciate about the Elephant and Piggie books by Mo Willems. He’s very clear about the characters’ species. I’m willing to admit that I might be wrong on this, though. Maybe it actually is cute and charming that it’s left up to us what exactly the characters are in We Are (Not) Friends. Right now, however, I find myself craving some clarity.

I’ve gotta be honest here: I have a deep admiration for the talents of Anna Kang and Christopher Weyant. From a superficial standpoint, their books are fairly simple and straightforward–great for children. But, if you dig deeper (or you’re a parent who ends up reading these books three or four million times to your children at night), you can find an incredible amount of subtext that speaks volumes about the human condition–which is both amazing and amusing since their books have yet to feature a human character.

4 out of 5 crayons


John Herzog is an illustrator and educator. His clients include Hasbro, Dreamworks TV, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, and Highlights for Children. He also teaches illustration classes at Ringling College of Art and Design. John is a member of the Society of Illustrators and SCBWI, and received the 2018 SCBWI Magazine Merit Award for his Highlights High Five cover illustration. He lives in Florida with his wife, two kids, a tarantula, a bearded dragon, and a fish.

He is represented by Shannon Associates.