Editor Interview: Frances Gilbert (Doubleday Books for Young Readers/​Random House Children’s Books)

This month’s Industry Insider is Frances Gilbert, Editor-​in-​Chief at Doubleday Books for Young Readers/​Random House Children’s Books. In addition to editing some of the top picture book writers working today, she also authored the picture books Go, Girls, Go! and Too Much Slime!, as well as numerous Step Into Reading titles and an abridgment of The Secret Garden. Among other things, Frances is well known for offering clear, supportive writing advice on social media and at writing conferences.

Let’s get to the interview to hear some of that wisdom ourselves firsthand!

Frances’ Twitter


RVC: At what point did you realize you were absolutely going to work in publishing? 

FG: I grew up in a blue collar family in a blue collar town where people didn’t have jobs like the one I have now. When I got to University of Toronto, I was surrounded by élite students whose parents had jobs I didn’t even know existed.

One friend’s mother was a sales rep at a big publisher. I asked if I could visit her office and as soon as I saw the stacks of books in everyone’s cubicles, I decided it was the place for me. She actually tried to talk me out of it! I think she was pretty burnt out. But in my head I kept thinking, “Nope, nope. This is what I’m going to do.”

RVC: What happened next?

FG: A couple of lucky breaks. A friend noticed a posting on a job board at University of Toronto while I was finishing my Master’s degree in English. It was for a Book Club Editor at Scholastic Canada. I knew I wanted to work in publishing but had my sights set on literary fiction. I applied anyway and was hired by the brilliant and wonderful Iole Lucchese, who thankfully read to page two of my resume and saw that I’d worked in the children’s department of my town library for four years in high school. She saw potential that I’d completely missed. Within days of starting, I knew I wanted a career in children’s books.

RVC: What kind of duties does a Book Club editor have? 

FG: A Book Club Editor manages the monthly book club—those flyers we all ordered from as kids. My responsibility was to select and purchase the Canadian content for each list, in addition to writing the copy and hitting monthly financial targets, so I was essentially a book buyer with a large business to manage and account for. I met with every Canadian publisher a few times a year and liaised with my counterpart in the New York office. Looking back, I still can’t believe they gave me such a big job. It allowed me to leap over assistant and associate positions and start right in the deep end. I was so lucky.

RVC: This might seem like a silly question, but I know people are wondering. Were books being published by Scholastic Canada solely for the Canadian marketplace? 

FG: Like any publisher, Scholastic Canada publishes primarily for their own country first, the Canadian marketplace, but not exclusively. Every publisher also has an international sales and foreign rights team who both sell English language copies around the world and license the rights to foreign translations.

RVC: How much French did you pick up while there?

FG: I lived in Canada from age five till I was thirty and took French in school through my second year of university, so I can get around in French at a schoolgirl level.

RVC: Très cool! Now, what are your thoughts on the Tim Hortons Double Double?

FG: I picked up a Tim Hortons Double Double each morning on my way to work. I still hit one up as soon as I land in Canada. Not Double Double anymore, but it’s still my favorite coffee.

RVC: Before getting to Doubleday where you’re at now, you spent a good bit of time working at Sterling (for those of you who don’t know, it’s owned by Barnes & Noble).

FG: Sterling was family-​owned when I was hired. I knew them as one of my suppliers for Book Clubs and Book Fairs. I bought books from them. The owner wanted to start a children’s editorial division and asked if I was interested in moving to New York to set one up. I was twenty-​nine when I got the offer, and had never actually edited a book, as my position was as a buyer and product manager.

RVC: What were some of the highlights of working at Sterling?

FG: Looking back, Sterling’s family-​owned, maverick spirit was certainly a highlight. They were nimble and independent and could take chances. When I protested during my interview that I had no editorial experience, they said, “You’ll learn!” And I did! I’ve often described those early years as “I’ve got a barn, let’s put on a show.” I was teaching myself a lot of stuff on the spot, but I had their full support to find my place. I’ll always be grateful to the former Sterling owners and executives for what they did for me. We had a large and very profitable children’s business when I left twelve years later.

RVC: How is working for Doubleday (a Big 5 publisher) different than what you experienced at your previous editorial jobs?

FG: The feeling of coming to Random House was definitely that of arriving at the Mother Ship. It’s impossible not to be impressed by basically everything–the resources, the systems, the offices, the history, the authors, the backlist, the bestsellers, the brilliant and in many cases legendary staff. But in some ways, my job was very similar to the one I left. Doubleday Books for Young Readers hadn’t published anything for a number of years when Chip Gibson, then the President of Random House Children’s Books, asked me to come over and see what I could do with it. Just like when I started at Sterling, I had to build a business from the ground up, so that was a task I was really comfortable with at that point.

RVC: Let’s help some of the aspiring writers out there. What’s a common misconception about kidlit editors?

FG: I know our industry can feel opaque when you’re trying to break in. One thing I always let people know is that we’re always earnestly trying to find exciting new works. I think people have the idea that we enjoy rejecting things, when in truth it’s the opposite. We’re always avidly trying to find great writing. We don’t enjoy saying “No” as often as we must. “Yes” is always more exciting.

RVC: What kind of things are you most looking for with picture book submissions?

FG: I’m always looking for that intangible thrill you get when you read something and it grabs you, either because it’s incredibly unique or stunningly beautiful or blistering funny. It’s hard to quantify but I know it when I see it. One thing none of us are looking for is formulaic writing. I do worry that picture book manuscripts fall into this category too often. I’m not looking for anything that simply ticks a lot of boxes that someone has heard in a seminar. That’s not how it works.

RVC: One more question for aspiring writers—what are your feelings on art notes? 

FG: If I don’t know what you envision happening in the book without art notes, then give me art notes. It’s that simple. I don’t understand why people worry about them so much.

RVC: In November 2019, you tweeted, “Gulp, so I’m a published book author.” How did your debut picture book Go, Girls, Go! come about?

FG: I actually wrote Go, Girls, Go! as a sort of practice piece. I was thinking about how most cars and trucks books have male characters behind the wheel and wondered what one would look like if we featured girls instead. I wrote it quickly and then put it away for a couple of years, never meaning to have it published. But I kept stumbling across it and finally shared it with a handful of editors. Andrea Welch at Beach Lane /​ Simon & Schuster clicked with it and made me an offer, and I ran about my apartment screaming. The feeling was as if I’d never set foot in the industry before. It was such a thrill.

RVC: What was the most important lesson you learned thanks to that book?

FG: I learned how important it is for authors to roll up their sleeves and really hustle for their books. It became like a second job to me in the evenings, writing to people, begging for favors, posting online. Now that I’ve done it myself, I feel even more emboldened in expecting it of the authors I work with.

RVC: How do your various identities—editor and author—inform each other?

FG: Certainly as an editor I can already envision how a manuscript I’m writing will fit into a publisher’s program—how it will be pitched at list launch, how it will be positioned within the larger list of books, what kind of marketing hooks the sales, marketing, and publicity team can use to help them sell and promote the book. Basically, all the things I think about when I’m acquiring, I also think about when I’m pitching one of my own manuscripts.

RVC: You’ve gone on to publish more picture books. Which one has the most unusual path to publication story?

FG: I have a new picture book coming out with Beach Lane /​ Simon & Schuster next spring. I wrote it during the first summer of the pandemic after receiving an email from an environmental group in my neighborhood. The subject line of the email sparked an idea and I immediately went out on my deck and wrote Can You Hug a Forest? I felt like I knew the entire manuscript in that one second; it just landed in my head and there it was. One moment you’re not thinking about writing something, the next moment you have an entirely new manuscript to share with your editor.

RVC: Do reviews hit you differently as a writer versus an editor?

FG: I’m thick-​skinned as both an author and an editor and can easily read a negative review and think, “Well, you didn’t understand what I was trying to do, and that’s too bad for you that you’re missing out on something really nice.”

RVC: In all of your experience as a picture book author, what has surprised you the most?

FG: How much I love doing it! I was an editor for close to twenty-​five years before it even occurred to me to write something. I can’t explain why; it just never crossed my mind. Being a writer has opened up a whole new part of my imagination.

RVC: What’s next for you as a picture book author? 

FG: Outside of Can You Hug a Forest?, which comes out next May, I don’t have a new manuscript in the works. I have to get on it!

RVC: Here’s one last question for this part of the interview. Who sets the standard for picture book rhyming?

FG: John Robert Allman, author of A Is for Audra and B Is for Broadway on my list at Doubleday. He uses rhyme so smartly to add sass and humor. It’s brilliantly inventive, like he’s landing a quadruple axel in each line.

RVC: Alright, Frances. Now it’s time for THE SPEED ROUND. Boomy-​zoomy question followed by zappy-​cracky answers, please. Are you ready?

FG: Hit me.

RVC: What would you most want—personal chef, maid, or a masseuse?

FG: Paul Hollywood baking in my kitchen all day.

RVC: What makes you roll your eyes every time you hear/​see it?

FG: The phrase “cancel culture.”

Samuel West, who indeed has a mellifluent voice!

RVC: If someone narrated your life, who would you want to be the narrator?

FG: The actor Samuel West, who has the most perfect voice on the planet.

RVC: What’s your editing superpower?

FG: I make really quick decisions. I know what I like the second I see it.

RVC: What’s a picture book you;ve edited that’s more awesome than the world realizes?

FG: Philip Stead’s I’d Like to Be the Window for a Wise Old Dog is an absolute masterpiece. Everyone who reads it will see I’m right. I don’t think it gets any better than this.

RVC: Your picture book philosophy in five words or fewer?

FG: “Grab me from line one.”

RVC: Thanks so much, Frances! This has been delightful. 

FG: Thank you for your great questions!

Educational Activities: Super Pizza & Kid Kale by Phaea Crede

Super Pizza & Kid Kale
Author: Phaea Crede
Illustrator: Zach Smith
27 September 2022
Viking Books for Young Readers
40 pages

Book description from Goodreads: “With great flavor, comes great responsibility.

Super Pizza and Kid Kale have been delicious do-​gooders and the best of friends since the day they came aleaf in the oven of the Baker Elementary cafeteria. But as they heroically foil one dastardly deed after another, Super Pizza’s popularity begins to go to their crust, and it leaves their veggie pal feeling rotten. The growing frustration that begins to drive a wedge in their friendship is now threatening to take the students of the school down with them! It’ll be up to Super Pizza and Kid Kale to patch things up so that they can get back to being the heroes that these kids knead.

For fans of Lady Pancake and Sir French Toast comes a hilarious and punny new picture book about navigating the ups and downs of friendship and the unintended consequences that actions can have on others, starring the Batman and Robin of food.”


Educational Activities inspired by Super Pizza & Kid Kale:

  • Before Reading–From looking at the front and back cover: 
    • What do you think about pizza?
    • What do you think about kale?
    • Where and when do you think this story takes place?
    • What differences do you see between the two superheroes on the front cover and the back cover?
    • What questions would you like to ask the author before you read the book?
  • After Reading–Now that you’ve read the story: 
    • How did you react when Kid Kale got upset about being ignored and undervalued?
    • Super Pizza & Kid Kale has a graphic novel/​comic illustration style. Why do you think the artist chose this style for this story?
    • Which of the pictures did you enjoy the most?
    • The book is full of puns (jokes that come from possible different meanings of a word, or words that have multiple meanings). Which were your favorites?
    • Did you like this book? Why/​why not?
  • Writing–The origin story of these unusual superheroes is a “freak cafeteria accident” on page one. What other school-​based superheroes might emerge from a different freak accident? Write one of those origin stories, and if you want, write one of their adventures, too. Use colored pencils, crayons, or markers to create your own story art, whether it’s comic-​style like Super Pizza & Kid Kale or something else entirely. Consider sharing your school superhero story with a friend or family member.
  • Crafting–Who knew there were so many kid crafts about pizza! OPB did, and here are a few of our favorites: 
  • Further Reading–Which of these books about pizza have you already read? Which of the others would you want to read first? (Click on any book cover for more information on these titles!)

Cover Reveal: My Grandpa, My Tree, and Me by Roxanne Troup

I never want to drop a lone image in a Cover Reveal post without offering a bit more, so enjoy this bonus mini-​interview with author Roxanne Troup about her debut trade picture book, My Grandpa, My Tree, and Me (Yeehoo Press, March 2023). If you want more from Roxanne, check out the full-​length interview we did at OPB earlier this week.

Why are there TWO covers here?” you might be asking. The first one is the cover proper, and the one below it is the cover beneath the dust jacket–the “under cover,” as Roxanne called it. That makes this a two-​fer cover reveal, folks!

RVC: What’s the most important thing people should know or understand about My Grandpa, My Tree, and Me?

RT: That it’s about more than trees. It’s about family, and while (like a growing tree) family changes over time, love only multiplies.

RVC: What’s your favorite line from the book?

RT: The very last one…but I won’t spoil that. So, I’ll go with my “next favorite” which appears on the second spread.

Every winter, while the trees stand silent under a sleepy sun…”

RVC: What are your current book launch plans?

RT: Am I supposed to know that already?!

RVC: Hah. Maybe?

RT: I guess, now I know what I’m doing in October. 😉

I’ve actually been busy working on the teacher guide and new school visit presentation for the book, but since no one grows pecans in Colorado, I may end up doing two “launches”—a small celebration here with writing pals and family, and another back home in Missouri (with a school visit attached) where the pecans will just be leafing out for a new production year.

RVC: Last question: what’s been your favorite part about working with Yeehoo Press?

RT: Seeing the artwork for the first time was fantastic, but I love that (after the contract) everything at Yeehoo has moved relatively quickly. And I’m super excited to see the book produced simultaneously in English and Chinese. How cool is that?

RVC: Cool indeed! Best of luck with the book, Roxanne. And thanks for letting OPB be part of your kidlit journey!

Author Interview: Roxanne Troup

Welcome to Roxanne Troup, the subject of our September Author Interview.

These days, Roxanne lives in Colorado where she writes children’s books, hikes in the mountains, and cheers on her kids at sporting events. She also “visits schools to water seeds of literacy and teach about writing. (And sometimes remembers to water the plants in her own garden.)”

In addition to being the author of more than a dozen children’s books, she’s also a ghostwriter, a work-​for-​hire writer, a speaker, and a history fan (“I find history fascinating because it’s full of stories. But I only realized that as an adult. As a kid, I only remembered the history I lived.”)

Need a few fun facts, too? Try these:

  • She’s afraid of octopuses.
  • She grew up in a historic home along the waterways of Missouri.
  • She’s a certified chocolate lover (“If they gave out licenses for this, I’d definitely have one!”)

Let’s move straight to the interview to find out more about our new writer pal!


 RVC: You’ve got a very unusual story about how you discovered your love of reading. Care to share?

RT: I was an early reader. And while I don’t remember ever not reading, I vividly remember the summer I fell in love with reading. I was seven, and my little brother wasn’t too happy about it. He wanted to play imaginary games with me, not watch me read “boring books.” But I’d recently broken my neck in a tumbling accident, and after spending nearly six months in a neck brace followed by more months of physical therapy (and intermittent neck-​brace-​wearing), I’d gotten used to “boring.” For over a year, I couldn’t ride my bike or play on our swing set without wearing the brace. But I could read. And I read everything I could get my hands on.

RVC: Wow!

RT: During the school year, I was in the library every day. I sped through easy readers by Syd Hoff and Peggy Parrish. I checked out everything my library had by Judy Blume and Beverly Cleary. And that summer, I read whatever I could find in our house—from Disney’s Encyclopedia of Knowledge to old books like Life with Father. (And by “old,” I mean old. My dad was a teacher who couldn’t stand the thought of throwing books away, so every time his school updated their curriculum or the library updated their collection, we did too. Our attic was full of books!) Then, I stumbled upon Pippi Longstocking and The Borrowers and time disappeared. Reality melted away. I was no longer reading because I didn’t have anything else to do. I was hooked. I read those books over and over and over again.

RVC: I know exactly what you mean about reality melting way when you find the right books. It seems like you had every intention of being a lifelong educator. What appealed about the classroom?

RT: All the things I love about writing for kids: The curiosity; the creativity and resourcefulness; the humor. Kids are intuitively confident and smart. They’re artists, athletes, mathematicians, scientists, and engineers—all the things they forget they are and wish they could be as preteens. If I could help nurture that innate wonder and willingness to fail, even for a short time, I wanted to.

RVC: When did you first consider yourself to be a writer?

RT: Not until 2016. Even though I was consistently making money writing (I got my first writing-​related paycheck in 2009), it wasn’t until I decided to focus on kidlit that I started calling myself a “writer.” Instead, I’d say things like “I’m doing some freelance work” or “I’m ghostwriting.” Writing was something I did to help put food on the table and gas in the car. It wasn’t who I was. It took really immersing myself in the kidlit industry (and publishing my first kid’s book) to change that perspective.

RVC: Normally, I spend more time outlining an interview subject’s career and writing arc, but I want to jump ahead here. Why? Because I’m fascinated by how you’re keeping up successful careers as a picture book author, ghostwriter, freelance writer, freelance editor, and speaker. And all without an agent. Clearly, you have a good sense of the business side of things. So, how do you balance the creative side of writing with the business side?

RT: Some days not very well. But I had an epiphany a few years ago that if I wanted to do the thing I loved (write picture books), I had to start balancing and pruning my writing activities until all the writing I did connected to children’s books/​education in some way. I have an in-​depth presentation on this topic that I’ve given at my local SCBWI, but essentially, I discovered my writing niche—the thing that allows me to meet my goals (get paid via writing, get published under my own name, and write something I enjoy) without draining my creative reserves or taking time away from my family. Before that, I lived at the mercy of my inbox.

RVC: Please tell me more.

RT: Not to bore anyone, but as an example: I never advertised my ghostwriting services. Still, word has a way of getting around, and after a year or two ghosting, I found myself with so many clients I couldn’t do anything else. My family began feeling the pressure and I became frustrated. My clients were needy. They came to me unprepared, and, while the whole family enjoyed my paychecks, I didn’t enjoy what I was doing. So, I raised my fees to weed out clients and maintain my earnings, which gave me more time to do what I loved. I repeated that process several times before eventually deciding I wouldn’t take on any more adult ghosting clients. (I do still ghost for a few clients/​publishers I have a track record with.) Instead, I would focus on kidlit. Now I consult with one of the most prestigious ghosting firms in the nation—working almost exclusively on picture books. I have more time. I still get paid to write, and it’s good practice doing what I love. I’ve done that in each of my freelance service areas, and while there are still days that feel more “business‑y” and less “kidlit‑y” and creative than I like, publishing is a business that requires both. So, I just remind myself of that and work toward a better-​for-​me balance the next day. And on the days I don’t have anything pressing, I work on my own projects. It’s still not a perfect balance, but it is getting better.

RVC: If you had to make a pie chart or Venn diagram to show your writing career right now, what would it look like?

RT: Nothing in real life is this neat and tidy, but in general, I spend the bulk of my writing time on…

RVC: How many different projects are you typically working on at any one moment?

RT: It varies from week to week (and I tend to think/​schedule in monthly chunks), so I’m not exactly sure how to answer this except to say—several.

Some of my work is seasonal, like writing websites for schools. Other stuff is tied to publishing cycles—like my upcoming picture book release—so even though it’s on my calendar, the work I need to do for it is sporadic. I nearly always have two or three different freelance projects in various stages of development on my monthly calendar, as well as trade market research and submissions to track (and, on occasion, contract negotiations!). Depending on the season, I may also have education market projects happening—but when I do, I try to limit the amount of time I dedicate to freelance gigs. I’m still building my income stream for speaking, so that piece of the pie is also sporadic. Everything considered, it’s unusual if I don’t have a least one writing-​related deadline each week.

RVC: Let’s talk books. This year, you’ve got not 1, not 2, not 3, not 4, not 5, but 6!!! kidlit books coming out this fall. These aren’t traditional trade books, but rather work-​for-​hire. Please explain the difference.

RT: Trade books are the books you’re familiar with; you find them in bookstores and associate each one to a specific author. Typically, that author has created the book from scratch and “sold” it to a publisher. (Publishers don’t actually buy books/​manuscripts. They purchase “rights” to a work—like the exclusive right to publish and sell a work in English, or the right to create an audiobook of the work, etc. Each of these rights is negotiated in a contract between the creator and the publisher, but unless sold, the copyright always remains with the creator.) Often, creators receive an advance against royalties for these books, and since they receive a royalty off every book sold, they’re heavily invested in marketing and promotion.

Work-​for-​hire books are different—from the copyright level up. Work-​for-​hire is a copyright term that means, “work made on behalf of another, in which the commissioner owns the copyright.” (That’s my layman’s definition.) It’s sometimes referred to as “work made for hire” or WFH. Work-​for-​hire can be anything from ghostwriting to the creative work you do as an employee. But in all WFH, the individual or company that hires you to create the work owns the copyright to whatever you created. Once the work is completed and you are paid, the individual or company can do what they like with that work—edit it, publish it, sell it, whatever—it belongs to them. Sometimes the creator gets credit for works made for hire. Sometimes they don’t. In general, WFH writers are paid a flat-​fee for their work, and thus are not expected to promote it.

RVC: Thanks for the explanation here. How does WFH work in kidlit?

RT: In kidlit, work-​for-​hire typically involves two markets: the education market and IP, or intellectual property. The education market is work created for (and sold to) schools and libraries. Publishers generate the ideas for these books/​series based on school curriculum and market need. They’re not typically available in bookstores, but authors do get credit for them. And since educational publishers have established relationships/​reputations with the schools and libraries that purchase these books, authors can expect that lots and lots of kids will read their work.

The IP market includes anything an author didn’t think up themselves. It can be a series cooked up by a publisher/​packager to meet a market demand, ghostwriting, or a book featuring licensed characters like Spider-​Man. IP books are generally sold in bookstores alongside other trade books. And, for the author, can range from flat-​fee to royalty-​based contracts (though you should expect any royalty to be lower than what you’d receive from a work you thought up and created yourself). These books sell really well! Some of your favorite series might even be on the list.

If you’re interested in learning more about work-​for-​hire writing, specifically in the education market, I have an article on LinkedIn you might enjoy.

RVC: What are some of the unexpected benefits of writing work-​for-​hire kidlit?

RT: WFH is a great source of additional income. Unlike trade projects, WFH is a guaranteed sale/​paycheck. It keeps me writing (which we all know is a necessary part of improving craft) and gives me experience working with and thinking like editors. It builds my portfolio and can give me books for use in soliciting author visits. And because WFH is generally flat-​fee, I’m not expected to participate in marketing—which, especially this year with six books coming out in one season, is a relief. (Can you imagine having to promote six books at once!?!?)

RVC: I sure hope so since I’ve got six coming out next year. Let’s talk about that later! Now, how are you getting these deals without an agent?

RT: With the exception of IP projects, most agents don’t handle WFH deals. The flat-​fee model just isn’t worth it for them. So, I contact publishers/​packagers directly with a submissions packet. A WFH submissions packet includes a cover letter expressing your interest and areas of expertise, a resume/​CV, and targeted writing samples. The publisher keeps your info on file and contacts you with projects that fit your experience and/​or samples.

RVC: What about the ghostwriting gigs?

RT: The ghostwriting I do for adults has all happened organically. The kidlit ghostwriting I do comes both organically and through the firm I consult with. I’d love to get more licensed character IP work—especially in the early reader and chapter book markets—but from what I understand, those jobs typically route through an agent or established editorial relationships.

RVC: Are you actively seeking an agent?

RT: Yes and no. I don’t currently have anything out with agents, but if I see that someone is reopening to subs or has a specific wish list item that fits what I create, I don’t hesitate to query. I’m just not spending a ton of time researching agents or sending them work. I’m not opposed to working with an agent—I’d love to be able to walk through the doors an agent can open for me—I’m just not waiting around for one either. I know, whether I have an agent or not, my career is in my hands.

RVC: What’s the most common misconception about work-​for-​hire work?

RT: That it’s a fast and easy “back door” into publishing. While WFH timelines are shorter (books typically release a year or less after contract), the work itself does not require any less effort. Good writing is good writing regardless of genre or sales avenue. And readers are readers. They deserve for authors to be just as meticulous with research, just as purposeful with word choice and mechanics, just as enthusiastic and creative (if appropriate) with WFH as any other contract.

RVC: You’re doing a lot of adult work, too, with your writing. In what ways does that affect your kidlit efforts?

RT: I do try to limit the amount of adult work I’m taking on so I don’t completely derail my kidlit efforts. But even adult projects are beneficial. The paychecks I get for adult freelance work helps subsidize the work I really want to do. It also improves my writing craft and marketing skills. To succeed in this industry, I have to be able to transfer thought to page in a coherent manner. I also have to be able to “sell” myself and/​or my work to agents, editors, booksellers, parents, teachers who might want to invite me into the classroom, and all sorts of other “gate keepers” (which is really just an ominous-​sounding phrase for book buyers.) And all those things take practice. Adult freelance forces me to practice.

RVC: This is a picture book blog, so I have to ask this—what’s the story of your first published picture book, My Grandpa, My Tree, and Me (Yeehoo Press, March 2023)?

RT: Somewhere on social media, I saw a post about a new publisher. I went to their website and saw they were looking for agricultural books so I started researching. When I ran across a YouTube video of a farmer harvesting pecans, I knew I had my topic. I couldn’t get the image of the farmer shaking that tree out of my head—all those pecans falling like torrential rain.

Growing up in a farming community, I had some experience with agriculture and pecans. But no one I knew harvested pecans by tractor. We gathered pecans like the wild products they were, not from hundreds of trees at a time. This dichotomy provided the structure of the story, and my first draft came together quickly.

Unfortunately, I was the most experienced writer in my critique group and started submitting before I should have. I sent the manuscript to four different publishers with no response. On the fifth try an editor saw enough potential in the work to request an R&R (revise and resubmit). I didn’t agree with the direction they wanted me to take the story, but tried to figure out what underlying issue they were pointing out. Eventually I realized my draft was too “education market‑y.” I had to figure out how to make it work for the trade market. I went back to work and a month or so later had an opportunity to submit my new draft to the wonderful Katie Heit at Scholastic. The story was too quiet for Scholastic’s list, but she was so complimentary I knew I’d hit the right note with my revisions. I spent the next year-​and-​a-​half submitting, but now, I was getting responses.

I finally found my publisher in May of ’21—Yeehoo Press. Yeehoo pubs picture books that work for both the US and Chinese markets, so my informational fiction was perfect for them. Four months later, it was official. My first trade PB was under contract!

Yeehoo contracted Kendra Binney to illustrate. Her soft watercolors were the perfect pairing for my lyrical text. I’m excited for its upcoming cover reveal!

RVC: What was the most valuable lesson that book taught you?

RT: To be patient—and keep working. Good writers get turned down all the time. Published writers get turned down, too. But as cliché as it sounds, it really does take just one “yes.” Publishing is a partnership. You have to be patient to find the perfect partner for your particular story, and you have to keep working to make sure your story is the perfect fit for a particular publisher.

RVC: Please talk about the role of community in your writing life.

RT: When I first started writing kidlit, I couldn’t justify the cost of writing classes or even an SCBWI membership. But I joined Laura Purdie Salas’ Facebook group for writers (now defunct) and started lurking and learning. Laura taught me a ton—just by following her career and reading her comments on people’s posts. She was so helpful and kind, but also honest. When she created Writing for the Educational Market, I knew it would be practical and encouraging, just like her. I purchased it immediately and got my first book contract shortly thereafter. I highly recommend her workshop-​in-​a-​book to everyone interested in the education market. It’s full of info I couldn’t find anywhere else. (And believe me; I looked!)

RVC: Thanks to your rec, I just ordered a copy myself. Watch out, educational market!

RT: After a few WFH books, I wanted to jump the fence, so to speak, into the trade market. Laura’s career convinced me it was possible, but I needed to find a regular critique group—not just occasional online swapping partners. So, I joined SCBWI and started getting involved in my local group. It was so refreshing to find people who got what I was trying to do. They understood the struggles of writing kidlit, but also the joy of finally finishing a decent draft.

Today, I co-​lead that group. And over the years, I’ve come to realize how incredibly generous and supportive the entire kidlit community is—if you are willing to put in the work.

RVC: What’s your most important good writing habit or routine?

RT: To write—whether I feel like it or not. I can’t wait for the muse to strike. I have deadlines. I have to get something on the page. If it’s no good, I can edit it. But I can’t edit a blank page. Eventually, if I put in the work, I’ll have something I’m proud of.

RVC: Lastly, what advice do you give to aspiring picture book writers?

RT: Learn the business and take the time to develop your craft. While writing may be creative, publishing is a business. You have to get both right to be successful. How? Read. A lot. Write even more. And find a group of creatives who can help you get better (not just those who will gush over whatever you create).

RVC: One final question for this part of the interview. Beyond the six work-​for-​hire books coming out this fall, what’s something upcoming that you’re really excited about?

RT: My debut trade picture book releases in March. That’s really exciting! (As a newbie, I’m still not sure what all that will entail, but I’m doing my best to learn as I go.) And I just signed a contract for another trade picture book slated for Spring 2024.

RVC: Congrats on that, Roxanne. But now the first part of the interview is over. Now it’s time for…the…LIGHTNINGROUND!!! Are you ready?

RT: Ready.

RVC: What secret talent do you have that few would expect?

RT: I randomly remember lines to songs and movies from my childhood and use them in everyday life. When my children are being overly emotional—“Calm yourself, Iago” (in the voice of Jafar from Disney’s Aladdin). When my mother-​in-​law finally goes home—“I think we’re alone now” (from Tommy James and the Shondells). When someone asks me a stupid question—“It’s possible, pig” (as Westley from The Princess Bride)—though not always out loud!

RVC: Pick a theme song that describes where your life is at right now.

RT: “The Hustle” by Van McCoy.

RVC: What picture book author would you want to write YOUR life story?

RT: She doesn’t write nonfiction, but Beth Ferry. I love everything she creates.

RVC: Five things you can’t do your work without.

RT: A computer and Internet connection, Microsoft Office, a big desk calendar, and the library.

RVC: Who sets the standard for picture books about history?

RT: Oh gosh. There are so many really good ones … Barb Rosenstock.

RVC: What’s the best compliment a child ever gave you or your books?

RT: Now, I get it!

RVC: Thanks so much, Roxanne! And for those of you who read to the very end, OPB has a treat for you. Watch for an OPB cover reveal this week for Roxanne’s forthcoming picture book, My Grandpa, My Tree, and Me!

Picture Book Review: Blue Baboon Finds Her Tune by Helen Docherty

Author: Helen Docherty
Illustrator: Thomas Docherty
Sourcebooks Jabberwocky
6 September 2022
32 pages

This month’s PB review is by Ryan G. Van Cleave (Owner/​Operator of Only Picture Books) and Connecticut-​based author/​illustrator Abi Cushman.

–Ryan’s Review of the Writing–

In this simple rhyming book by Helen and Thomas Docherty, Blue Baboon shows up at a park where an animal music trio is jamming. Since Blue Baboon notices a bassoon just waiting there for someone to play it, she gives it a shot. Only she’s not musically talented, so Elephant yanks back the instrument.

A storm ends the scene, and leaves a drippy Blue Baboon wandering until she sees a hot-​air balloon. As the balloon goes up, up and away, Elephant hands her the bassoon as Blue Baboon sails off to a sand dune where she runs into Green Baboon–someone who appreciates her out-​of-​tune music at last. Why? Because Green Baboon croons out of tune.

The text is minimal–perhaps a few dozen words in total, with most of them rhyming with “Baboon.” As so often happens with such a strict adherence to rhyme, the story gets a bit illogical (like the sudden appearance of a monsoon, or how Elephant inexplicably gives away a bassoon), but overall, early educators and parents can use this book to introduce very young readers to colors, animals, musical instruments, and rhymes.

The selling point is the fine artwork and the cute animals, which I’ll let Abi discuss in full, though I’ll note that even I noticed the teensy red balloon with a heart in it on every spread. Charming.

All in all, it’s a fun, sweet book.

4.25 out of 5 pencils

 

–Abi’s Review of the Illustrations–

In Blue Baboon Finds Her Tune, Thomas Docherty’s playful illustrations are a real delight. They are bright, bold, and fun. I love the energy and vibrancy he instills in the nighttime city scenes and his expressive, endearing characters. With this sparse text, which is primarily driven by the sound of the words, Thomas does the heavy lifting when it comes to storytelling. Kids will not only enjoy watching Blue Baboon on her adventure, they will also have fun following the red balloon that drifts into the sky and makes its way into all the subsequent scenes.

With music being a major part of the story, Thomas was tasked with finding a creative way to SHOW music, and he does a wonderful job of this, portraying sounds–both harmonious and out of tune–with whimsical stars and colored lightning bolts. The expressions on the surrounding characters’ faces when Blue Baboon doesn’t quite hit the right note really amps up the humor in the story as well.

Thomas includes several hints in the illustrations of what’s to come. For example in the initial scene, we see a sign advertising Nighttime Balloon Rides. In the scene where Blue Baboon is playing the bassoon, we see part of a cloud rolling in. But I think he could have pushed this even further and included even more of these hints and Easter eggs in the illustrations. Perhaps we could have seen a peek of the umbrellas that were apparently behind the bear in earlier scenes or a peek of Green Baboon’s tail behind the dune.

One illustration that might get a lot of attention is actually located on the back endpapers. Thomas brings all the characters back in a hot-​air balloon scene, like the cat family who lost the red balloon and the ducks from the park. Kids will enjoy flipping back through the book to follow those characters’ storylines more carefully.

All in all, I found Thomas’s illustrations to be chock full of kid appeal, and I think young readers will enjoy poring over these pictures again and again.

4.5 out of 5 crayons


Abi Cushman is the author-​illustrator of Animals Go Vroom! (Viking), Soaked! (Viking), and Wombats Are Pretty Weird (Greenwillow), which hits shelves in summer 2023. She has also worked as a web designer for over 15 years, and runs two popular websites of her own: MyHouseRabbit.com and AnimalFactGuide.com, which was named a Great Website for Kids by the American Library Association. In her spare time, Abi enjoys running, playing tennis, and eating nachos. (Yes, at the same time.) She lives on the Connecticut shoreline with her husband and two kids.

For exclusive sneak peeks, wombats, and special giveaways, subscribe to Abi’s newsletter.