Picture Book Review: Five-​Word Reviews (Guest Post: Lexi Hall)

This is the first time I’ve ever asked someone to do a five-​word review guest post, and I’m so excited to introduce Lexi Hall! She’s a children’s writer and illustrator living in Boston, where she works as the children’s bookseller at Beacon Hill Books & Café (imagine being surrounded by all those picture books!). She’s also pursuing her MFA in children’s book writing and illustration, and is even illustrating a forthcoming picture book, Enough Elizabeths.

I asked Lexi to find five new picture books that she digs, and I can’t wait to see what caught her eye. Let’s find out!


One Light
Author: Christie Matheson
Illustrator: Anuska Allepuz
Farrar, Straus and Giroux (BYR)

24 September 2024
40 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Timely. Powerful. One spark ignites. 

4.5 out of 5 lights in the darkness


Perfect
Author: Waka T. Brown
Illustrator: Yuko Jones
Quill Tree Books
1 October 2024
40 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Love-​mended treasures. Accepting flaws. Tender!

4.75 out of 5 kintsugi teacups


Pig Town Party
Author: Lian Cho
Illustrator: Lian Cho
HarperCollins
29 October 2024
40 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Mix-​up, costume contest, pig-​giggle fest!

4.25 out of 5 mud cakes


Sari Sisters
Author: Anitha Rao-​Robinson
Illustrator: Anoosha Syed
Viking Books for Young Readers
22 October 2024
32 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Sharing precious milestones, sisterly-​love story.

4.5 out of 5 sari dance parties!


The Verts
Author: Ann Patchett
Illustrator: Robin Preiss Glasser
HarperCollins
17 September 2024
40 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Crowded party? Solo-​celebration? Honoring differences.

4.25 out of 5 tinfoil stars


Lexi Hall is a children’s writer and illustrator from Pittsburgh PA. Growing up, she fell in love with writing and illustrating her own little stories to share with her friends. Now, she lives and works in Boston, MA as the children’s bookseller at Beacon Hill Books & Café, where she is spoiled with daily access to all the picture books she can read!

Lexi is pursuing her MFA in children’s book writing and illustration from Hollins University. She has illustrated for Hollins University Magazine and The Big Kit & Lil’ Kaboodle children’s magazine. She has also illustrated an upcoming 2025 picture book written by author Heather Harris Bergevin, Enough Elizabeths, with Lucky Rabbit Publishing.

Website: www.lexihall.com

Instagram: @lexi.paints

Five-​Word Reviews: All at Once Upon a Time; Don’t Invite a Bear inside for Hanukkah; Nocturnal Nico; Oak; When Love Is More Than Words

cover image All at Once upon a TimeAll at Once Upon a Time
Author: Mara Rockliff
Illustrator: Gladys Jose
Harry N. Abrams
10 September 2024
48 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Upside-​down classics. More mashup mayhem!

4 out of 5 giggles and guesses


Don’t Invite a Bear Inside for Hanukkah
Author: Karen Rostoker-​Gruber
Illustrator: Charles Arbat
Apples & Honey Press
5 November 2024
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Messy bear…meaningful holiday magic.

4.25 out of 5 latke laughs


Nocturnal Nico: A Bedtime Picture Book for Night Owls
Author: Gabe Jensen
Illustrator: Gabe Jensen
Familius
15 October 2024
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Late-​night fun with night-​loving friends.

3.75 out of 5 owl hoots


Oak: The Littlest Leaf Girl
Author: Lucy Fleming
Illustrator: Lucy Fleming
Candlewick
10 September 2024
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Courage through autumn’s chill. Leap!

4.25 out of 5 woodland wonders


Author: Jocelyn Chung
Illustrator: Julia Kuo
Nancy Paulsen Books
15 October 2024
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Love’s language lives in action.

4 out of 5 heartfelt hugs

Picture Book Review: Even Yetis Get Colds, by Carlianne Tipsey

Author: Carlianne Tipsey
Illustrator: Carlianne Tipsey
Pixel+Ink
29 October 2024
32 pages

This month’s PB review is by Ryan G. Van Cleave (Owner/​Operator of Only Picture Book) and freelance author/​illustrator Kelly Light.

–Ryan’s Review of the Writing–

Being best friends with a yeti might sound like a dream come true—after all, who wouldn’t want to have the “best seat in the house” while watching an outdoor movie or enjoy fresh-​picked fruit from the highest branches? Sign me up for a pal like that! But when that yeti gets a cold, things go downhill fast. In Even Yetis Get Colds, debut author-​illustrator Carlianne Tipsey introduces readers to a unique friendship where the young narrator, Coco, navigates the yearly challenge of curing their giant, sneezing, and grumpy yeti companion.

Coco’s persistence in finding a cure is endearing—stocking up on sweaters, blankets, and even attempting cross-​continental trips to tropical islands (in her imagination, of course). The gentle humor in her increasingly creative (and unsuccessful) efforts will resonate with young readers, especially as they see that sometimes, no matter how hard you try, all a friend really needs is your company.

The story celebrates the joys and challenges of friendship, especially when things aren’t perfect. Though light on plot and lacking a dynamic conclusion, the book’s heart lies in its message: sometimes, the best cure for a cold—or any bad day—is simply being there for someone you care about.

As a cryptid fan, I was hoping for a bit more oomph in the yeti theme. The title suggests a playful exploration of a cryptid’s world, but the story doesn’t fully delve into the fun possibilities that come with having a mythological creature for a friend. Cryptid-​inspired mischief, traits, or quirky details might have made this friendship feel even more special. Ultimately, this book is perhaps best suited for cozy reading sessions, where the focus is on togetherness rather than action-​packed adventure or cryptid surprises.

Overall, Even Yetis Get Colds is a gentle, heartwarming story with an appealing friendship at its core. Young readers (ages 4–7) will likely appreciate the book’s light humor and the reassuring message that sometimes, just being there for a friend is the best thing you can do.

3.75 out of 5 pencils

 

–Kelly’s Review of the Illustrations–

Welcome Carlianne Tipsy to traditional picture book shelves after building an online presence through marketing and independent publishing. Her debut as an author/​illustrator of a book for children is Even Yetis Get Colds, published by Pixel+Ink, an imprint of Holiday House.

In this digitally illustrated story, Coco has a best friend who is a giant blue monster—a yeti named … Yeti, who is helpful and supportive. It is fun to have a friend who can magically produce ice cream by blowing on an ice cream cone. The first spread introduces the friendship dynamic. The characters are drawn in poses that display “glee” with life and vitality.

The art is cute. It is made in Procreate on an iPad. Textured brushes and watercolor effects are used. The pastel palette is very candy-​colored. Tipsy has authored an independently published book titled How to Draw Adorably, which is how she draws. The yeti and the child, Coco, have broad, dark, dot eyes set low on the face. The art does feel animated, with some expression drawings having a bit of an animé influence when the happy, wide-​open mouths are drawn.

My favorite spread in the book is the drive-​in movie image on the second spread. The color shift and the full-​bleed image are nicely done, as is the aerial perspective on the cars. It is the most cinematic composition in the book.

On the fourth spread, the text describes coughs as windstorms and sneezes as blizzards, but the punchline “don’t make me tell you what happens when he…” is left undefined. It must be something gross! I am unsure what bodily function encases the two main characters in ice cubes, but they are—frozen in shocked expressions. This comedic touch is sure to make kids giggle. Throughout the book, the soft colors of the digital drawings maintain a feeling of goodness and fun, while the friendly character design is appealing.

The friendship dynamic flips and Coco becomes a supportive, helpful friend. The character’s acting in the drawings reflects this shift. The last spread in the book is the other fully illustrated double-​page spread that mirrors the first one of the drive-​in movie. Now they are cozy in a movie theater of Coco’s making for the ailing yeti. The art serves the text with Yeti now hugging Coco. It is a sweet end to a confection of a picture book.

3.75 out of 5 colored pencils


Kelly Light lives in Amherst, MA but grew up down the shore in New Jersey surrounded by giant pink dinosaurs, cotton candy colors, and Skee-​Ball sounds. She was schooled on Saturday-​morning cartoons and Sunday funny pages. She picked up a pencil, started drawing, and never stopped.

Kelly is the author/​illustrator of the Louise series. Louise Loves Art and Louise and Andie, The Art of Friendship are the first two picture books in the series. Louise Loves Bake Sales and Louise and The Class Pet are the first readers in HarperCollins’ I Can Read program.

Kelly has also illustrated Elvis and the Underdogs and Elvis and the Underdogs: Secrets, Secret Service, and Room Service by Jenny Lee, and The Quirks series by Erin Soderberg, as well as the upcoming 2026 picture book release written by author Samantha Berger, Corny, with Henry Holt & Co.

Website: www.kellylight.com

Five-​Word Reviews: The Boy and the Elephant; The River Is My Ocean; Thank You; Tiny Jenny; We Are Definitely Human

I’ve been reading so many picture books lately, and I can’t resist sharing some of my favorites! So, here are five mini-​reviews, each in just five words – because sometimes, that’s all you need to capture the magic.


Author: Freya Blackwood
Illustrator: Freya Blackwood
Random House Studio
27 August 2024
40 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Urban chaos. Serene sanctuary found.

4.25 out of 5 pachyderm pals


Author: Rio Cortez
Illustrator: Ashleigh Corrin
Denene Millner Books/​Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers
27 August 2024
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Hudson’s diasporic flow, intergenerational bond. 

4.25 out of 5 mermaids


Author: Jarvis
Illustrator: Jarvis
Candlewick
6 August 2024
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Deeply appreciated visual feast. Uplifting.

4.25 out of 5 collage moons


Anne Schwartz Books
6 June 2024
48 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Mischief-​maker finds true belonging. Enchanting.

4 out of 5 whimsical wrens


Author: X. Fang
Illustrator: X. Fang
Tundra Books
6 August 2024
48 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Aliens crash. Kindness blooms. Laughter!

4.5 out of 5 unexpected visitors

 

Picture Book Review: Socks: A Kid’s Christmas Lament by J.D. McPherson (illustrated by Anika Orrock)

Socks: A Kid’s Christmas Lament
Author: J.D. McPherson
Illustrator: Anika Orrock
Walker Books US
10 September 2024
40 pages

This month’s PB review is by Ryan G. Van Cleave (Owner/​Operator of Only Picture Books) and freelance illustrator Edna Cabcabin Moran.

Ryan’s Review of the Writing

***Note: I’ve been creating picture book reviews at OPB since 2018, and this is the first one I’ve covered which is linked to a song! Witness the QR code at the front of the book which leads to the song and animations. Fun!***

JD McPherson’s picture book, Socks, adapts his song of the same name, transforming a catchy tune into a heartwarming and humorous Christmas story. The book retains the song’s core concept—a child’s comical outrage at receiving socks for Christmas—but expands upon it with a richer narrative, deeper character development, and a more nuanced exploration of holiday themes.

The rhyming text, a hallmark of the original song, remains a driving force in the book. The rhymes are playful and varied, capturing the child’s frenetic energy as they search for hidden presents. The repetition of key phrases, particularly the lament over the “lousy pair of socks,” creates a humorous rhythm that young readers will delight in.

***Want to see the lyrics of the song for yourself? Here you go!***

McPherson’s vivid language and imagery elevate the story beyond the song’s lyrics. The child’s actions are described with dynamic verbs like “creep,” “peek,” and “rifle,” painting a picture of their frantic quest. The socks themselves are imbued with personality, described as something to “insulate” the child’s boots or their failure to “beep or buzz or bop.” These details add depth and humor, making the story a joy to read aloud.

While the song ends on a lighthearted note of defiance, the book offers a more quiet resolution. The child’s anger subsides as they witness their family’s joy and realize the importance of togetherness. This shift in perspective adds emotional depth and reinforces the book’s heartwarming message.

The book’s execution occasionally stumbles in its pursuit of rhyme and rhythm. While the majority of the rhymes are charming and effective, some lines feel forced. This is particularly noticeable in phrases like “impassioned declarations” and “I ruined no vacations,” where the multisyllabic words and unusual phrasing create an uneven cadence that (to some ears/​tongues) might disrupt the natural flow of the language.

Ultimately, Socks is a testament to the power of adaptation. McPherson successfully reimagines his song, creating a picture book that stands on its own merits. The story’s humor, relatable characters, and endearing message will resonate with young readers, making it a festive addition to any holiday collection.

4.25 out of 5 pencils


Edna’s Review of the Illustrations

The minimalistic cartoon style of Socks is befitting of this song-​inspired picture book. Chock full of energy and whimsy, the pages draw you in through a playful composition of line, shape and muted color blocks deftly rendered by illustrator, Anika Orrock.

The story is centered on a nameless boy who complains of getting socks for Christmas. Readers follow along as the boy searches in vain for gifts (other than socks) as his musings lead up to a sock protest in this jazzy-​blues stylized world.

Orrock depicts the boy frantically conducting a dimly lit, early morning search and winding up in a bright, joyful reveal of family festivities and coveted gifts. The story ends with Santa and Mrs. Claus cozying up with socked feet, on a bright North Pole morning. The sophisticated yet subtle transitions and treatment of light in the illustrations are one of my favorite things about this book.

Of special note are pages 28–29 which help to usher in the story’s climax in a side-​by-​side comparison of limited-​color cityscape featuring multilingual balloons versus a stark, colorless crowd of sock-​protesters carrying signs. Kudos to Orrock’s clever typographic treatment of “SOCKS” which is incorporated into a page turn.

Kids will enjoy discovering the sub-​stories and the clever hints on the boy’s personality and interests–see the Jolly Roger skull and crossbones on different objects and the “swear jar” among other things.

Readers can check out the book’s origin by clicking on the QR Code in the book’s front matter. This will take you to the YouTube page which hosts the original song performed by author/​songwriter JD McPherson. The album’s original art show the boy and a Christmas tree–obvious inspiration for the book’s main character and illustrative style.

Overall, I found the illustrations to be a delightful throwback to mid-​century cartoons, keenly drawn and composed and loads of fun to explore–key aspects to the success of this holiday story.

5 out of 5 candy canes


Edna Cabcabin Moran is an author/​illustrator, multi-​disciplined artist, educator, and advocate for youth voices and diversity in publishing. A Filipina-​American born to immigrants and raised in a military family, Edna grew up in the USA’s east and west coasts, Iceland, and Hawai’i. She is also a dancer with acclaimed hālau hula and dance company, Nā Lei Hulu I Ka Wēkiu, and a teaching artist specializing in STEAM and integrative arts. Her latest picture book, Honu and Moa (BeachHouse Publishing), received a 2019 Aesop Accolade from the American Folklore Society.

https://kidlitedna.com

IG: @kidlitedna

Five-​Word Reviews: Between Words; Building a Beak; Flamingos are Pretty Funky; The Mango Tree; What We Wear When We Take Care

All of the illustrators I was going to work with on picture book reviews this month are now occupied with working on new picture books. That’s a good “problem,” though, and it simply means OPB readers get another month of five-​word reviews.

Here goes!


Author: Saki Tanaka
Illustrator: Saki Tanaka
Orchard Books
21 May 2024
40 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Colorful journey of quiet connection.

4.5 out of 5 shared smiles


Author: Becca McMurdie
Illustrator: Diana Hernández
Page Street Kids
11 June 2024
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Hope blooms from broken beak.

4 out of 5 3D printers


Author: Abi Cushman
Illustrator: Abi Cushman
Greenwillow Books
4 June 2024
40 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Science, silliness, seriously flamboyantly flamingo-tastic.

4.25 out of 5 pink necks


Author: Edel Rodriguez
Illustrator: Edel Rodriguez
Harry N. Abrams
11 June 2024
48 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Friendship transcends borders. Wondrously wordless.

4.25 out of 5 marvelous mangoes


Author: Sarah Finan
Illustrator: Sarah Finan
Candlewick
18 June 2024
32 pages

Ryan’s five-​word review: Sensible symphony of safety sounds.

4 out of 5 yellow helmets