Picture Book List: 4 Picture Books That Showcase Kidlit Agents’ Favorite Elements—and Why They Shine

Last month, I shared a list of picture books that kidlit editors frequently mention, and I got a lot of nice notes about it! So, I’m bringing back the concept—this time with insights from some of the wonderful literary agents who are friends of the blog.

I asked four agents to name a picture book they often reference when talking to clients or writers about what makes a story shine. Each book showcases qualities that agents admire, from compelling narratives to unforgettable art. While I’m keeping their names private to avoid any unintended favoritism, their thoughtful feedback is reflected in the commentary below.

If the language is in quotation marks, it’s directly from the agents. The rest is from me. Enjoy!


Julian Is a Mermaid by Jessica Love

Why Agents Love It:

  • Economy of Text: “This book is proof that less can truly be more. Every word is purposeful, and the space between the lines lets the illustrations tell so much of the story.”
  • Celebration of Individuality: Julian’s journey of self-​expression is told with tenderness and authenticity, making it a standout example of how inclusive stories can feel universal without being preachy. “It’s the kind of book that shows you don’t need to explain everything—sometimes the best stories trust the reader to feel the message.”
  • Art That Transports You: The lush, painterly illustrations are a visual feast. “Every page feels like stepping into Julian’s world, and the quiet magic of the art lingers long after you close the book.”

Thank You, Omu! by Oge Mora

Why Agents Love It:

  • Timeless Themes: Omu’s generosity and the community’s gratitude create a feel-​good story that celebrates kindness and connection. “It’s one of those books that feels like it’s been around forever—and I mean that as the highest compliment.”
  • Unique Art Style: Mora’s collage illustrations are rich, textured, and vibrant. “There’s a warmth and energy to the artwork that makes every page feel alive. You can almost smell the stew simmering!”
  • Perfect for Read-​Alouds: With its rhythmic, repetitive structure, this book practically begs to be read aloud. “The storytelling cadence makes it a go-​to for libraries and classrooms—it’s a crowd-​pleaser every time.”

The Day You Begin by Jacqueline Woodson, illustrated by Rafael López

Why Agents Love It:

  • A Universal Yet Personal Theme: This book speaks to anyone who’s ever felt like they didn’t belong. “It’s a quiet powerhouse of a story—one that gives kids (and adults) permission to embrace their differences and share their truths.”
  • Lyrical Text: Woodson’s poetic language lends the story an emotional depth that lingers long after the last page. “The writing is so lyrical and beautiful, you almost want to read it aloud just to hear the words again.”
  • Stunning Illustrations: López’s bold, vibrant illustrations perfectly complement the text, capturing the emotions of the characters and drawing readers into the story. “The interplay between the words and art is magical—this is what picture books are all about.”

We Don’t Eat Our Classmates by Ryan T. Higgins

Why Agents Love It:

  • Humor with Heart: This hilarious story about a dinosaur learning to navigate the social challenges of school strikes the perfect balance between funny and heartfelt. “It’s laugh-​out-​loud funny, but it also sneaks in such a sweet message about kindness and empathy.”
  • Relatable Concept: Starting school is a major milestone, and this book cleverly addresses first-​day jitters in a way that feels fresh and engaging. “It’s such a smart take on school anxiety—familiar, but with a totally unexpected twist.”
  • Lasting Appeal: Its humor and relatability ensure that it’s a favorite for both kids and adults. “The kind of book parents don’t mind reading over and over—and believe me, that matters.”

If you’re a picture book creator, take note of what makes these books shine—they might just inspire your next project!

Reading Activities: Frostfire by Elly Mackay (Guest Post: Lexi Hall)

Frostfire
Author: Elly Mackay
Illustrator: Elly Mackay
1 October 2024
Tundra Books
44 pages

Book description from Goodreads: “Follow dragon-​expert Miriam and curious Celeste on a magical winter’s day walk through their garden, where a snow dragon just might be hiding! Elly MacKay’s luminous artwork and sweet sibling story will cast a spell over readers of all ages in this playfully imaginative picture book that’s perfect for fans of Frozen.

On a walk through a snow-​covered garden, big sister Miriam claims to hear the sound of a snow dragon. Little sister Celeste has lots of questions: snow dragons are real? Where do they hide? What do they eat? And is that frost on the greenhouse windows or is it … frostfire?

Miriam seems to have an answer for everything about snow dragons. But when Celeste wanders off, she has a magical encounter that changes everything she thought she knew.

Told through gently playful dialogue and brought to life with spectacular works of paper diorama art, Elly Mackay’s newest picture book is an enchanting wintertime adventure destined to become a classic seasonal fairy tale that readers will enjoy for years to come.”


Need some reviews of Frostfire?

Reading Activities inspired by Frostfire:

  • Before Reading–From looking at the front cover: 
    • What do you think the word Frostfire could mean?
    • What do you think could make frostfire?
    • What do you see behind the two foxes? Can you make up a name for it?
    • Do you think that the foxes are the same age? Which one might be older?
    • Why do you think they are out in the snow? Where could they be going?
    • What questions would you like to ask the author or the illustrator before reading the book?
  • After Reading–Now that you’ve read the story: 
    • How did Miriam know so much about snow dragons? Did she get anything wrong about them?
    • How does the snow dragon camouflage? Where does it go in the summertime?
    • What did Celeste give to the snow dragon?
    • How do you think the sisters felt when they both saw the snow dragon in the clouds?
    • How did the illustrations add to the story? How do you think Elly Mackay made them?
    • What do you think is the main message of the story?
    • Have you ever played games using your imagination?
    • Would you recommend this book to a friend? What part would you tell them about first?
  • Go Cloud Gazing: Lie down outside and look up at the sky like Celeste and Miriam. What sort of shapes do you see in the clouds? What creatures might be flying there, camouflaged as clouds?
  • Camouflage Your Own Dragon: Draw a dragon on paper using colored pencils, crayons, watercolors, or markers, and glitter! Cut out the shape. Find different places where your dragon blends in and think about why it might live in that habitat.
  • Treasure Hunt: Head outside and pretend you’re a snow dragon out in the wild! What sort of things would you take for your hoard? A pine cone? Acorn tops? Shiny pebbles?
  • Write Your Own Imaginary Creature: Imagine you are telling a tall tale to a friend or sibling! What sort of details can you create about a mysterious magical creature? Where does it live? What does it eat? Write a story about meeting one in the wild. Draw a picture of it! What sound does it make?
  • Further Reading: If you loved Frostfire, you might enjoy other books about mysterious, magical creatures and winter adventures. Which of these have you already read?

Margaret’s Unicorn by Briony May Smith

Margaret watches the herd leap from the mountain, fading into the clouds that streak across the sky. The unicorns had migrated for the winter, but they accidentally left a baby behind. It’s up to Margaret to care for him! This story gently holds the magic and wonder of childhood imagination.


Dear Yeti by James Kwan

Two young hikers venture into a winter wonderland in search of the mysterious and elusive yeti! Will their letters be enough to coax the shy creature out of hiding? A hilarious tale about making unlikely friends and being kind.


The Little Forest Keepers by Mary Lundquist

A story about being kind and open. Ash and Pudd are forest keepers! They take care of everything in the cold wintry wood. It’s very important that all of the animals have hats and scarves to keep warm. Even the trees need to be bundled up! One day, a strange new creature arrives, and Ash and Pudd have never seen anything like it before.


Owl Moon by Jane Yolen

Late one night, a little girl and her father go owling. It’s her first time, and she is so excited! But she must stay very quiet. She hopes their calls will work, and that they will spot an owl. A timeless story of the quiet beauty in a small moment.

 


Lexi Hall is a children’s writer and illustrator from Pittsburgh PA. Growing up, she fell in love with writing and illustrating her own little stories to share with her friends. Now, she lives and works in Boston, MA as the children’s bookseller at Beacon Hill Books & Café, where she is spoiled with daily access to all the picture books she can read!

Lexi is pursuing her MFA in children’s book writing and illustration from Hollins University. She has illustrated for Hollins University Magazine and The Big Kit & Lil’ Kaboodle children’s magazine. She has also illustrated an upcoming 2025 picture book written by author Heather Harris Bergevin, Enough Elizabeths, with Lucky Rabbit Publishing.

Website: www.lexihall.com

Instagram: @lexi.paints

Author/​Illustrator Interview: Angela Quezada Padron

成人快播' literary-themed March Madness tournament returns with an ...This month’s Author-​Illustrator Interview features Angela Quezada Padron, a Latina creator with a growing presence in children’s literature. Angela writes and illustrates picture books, board books, middle-​grade novels, and more, often highlighting diverse characters and stories inspired by her own background and experiences.

Alongside her creative pursuits, Angela has also worked as a freelance editor, educator, and fine artist, recently bringing her talents to Bushel & Peck Books as one of my Editorial Assistants. While we’ve worked together in that capacity, I thought this interview would be a great opportunity to learn more about her journey as an author-​illustrator and her creative process.

Let’s dive in and hear from Angela about her work, her inspirations, and what’s next!


RVC: You’ve been writing and illustrating since childhood. What was the first story or illustration you remember creating that made you think, “This is something I love to do”?

AP: Thank you so much for this opportunity to speak to you about my publishing career. I did a lot of writing and illustrating as a child. I used to create books with Snoopy as the main character. Sometimes I wrote about Santa or my mom when she was having a baby. I also took Creative Writing in middle school and loved the class. And I used to go to the public library and check out the Writer’s Market book to try and get greeting cards or stories published too. However, for some reason I didn’t think about writing as a career, probably because I was focused more on fine art and studying to be either a doctor or a teacher.

It wasn’t until I was in my early 30s when I got an original middle grade story idea in my head. I flushed out the character and the general plot and fell in love with writing again. That’s when I looked for an organization to help me and discovered SCBWI so I could learn about the business and craft of creating books.

RVC: We’ll circle back on SCBWI in a moment. Your journey began as an illustrator and educator before becoming an author-​illustrator. How did your teaching experience inspire you to write your own stories, and how has it influenced your creative process?

AP: As a teacher, I was surrounded by children’s books all day. When I would read with my students or take them to the library to check out books, I started looking at the books differently than when I read books as a child. I had a more analytic lens while teaching the students literary skills. I studied the language patterns and characters that the authors incorporated. Also, even though I was a fine artist, I had not seriously illustrated stories, so I began to pay more attention to the layout, style, and color palettes of the illustrations. I became engulfed in the imagination sparked by the stories like my students did, as if I were a child all over again. That ignited my creativity and story ideas blossomed. Then of course being around children all day, I was exposed to some interesting and unique personalities and backgrounds, which gave me ideas for some characters and story lines.

I knew I needed more education myself, though, so I completed an online MFA in Illustration through the Academy of Art University in 2011. That gave me the skills, experience, and confidence I needed to start promoting myself as an illustrator, which led me to illustrate two trade books and some educational material between 2012–2014.

RVC: Let’s talk about those books! As the Seas Rise is such a powerful author/​illustrator debut. What’s the story of how that book came to be?

AP: Thank you, I really enjoyed working on it. I had always loved nonfiction from the time I was a kid (shout out to my mom for getting us a home set of Encyclopedia Britannica!).

RVC: Encyclopedia Britannica? I swear, each volume weighed more than a sack of potatoes. Good times.

AP: I attended the Virtual SCBWI Nonfiction Conference in 2020 and heard some fabulous authors speak, like Carole Boston Weatherford and Lesa Cline-​Ransome. I became fascinated with the more narrative way that nonfiction was being written, and I also learned that there was a lack of diverse biographies, especially Latina figures. I did some research and found articles about Nicole Hernandez Hammer, who is a climate change scientist and activist originally from Guatemala. I found her on LinkedIn and reached out for a possible interview. She replied, and we met in Zoom where I was able to verify some information I had read about her. That gave me a good basis to write the manuscript. Once I got the book deal, I asked Nicole to consult on the book and she did, on both the text and art, throughout the entire process.

RVC: Nonfiction books often require balancing storytelling with factual accuracy. What challenges did you face in managing both the writing and illustrating of As the Seas Rise?

AP: I was lucky to be able to consult with Nicole throughout the entire book process. Without that, I think it would have been a difficult book to write because there is not much written about her; I would have been scrambling for ideas for some of the spreads. The text itself wasn’t too hard to write because it all fell into place quickly; I wanted it to sound “picture-​booky” and lyrical while also including the factual information in both the text and art. At the same time, this presented a challenge. Nicole had limited photo references from her childhood, and many of the photos were grainy or not sharp, as they often were in the 1970s. So, I had to try extra hard to make sure that I was illustrating her correctly and portraying her family members well so that it was as accurate as possible while also pleasing Nicole and my publisher.

RVC: You work across genres, from board books to middle grade novels. How does your process differ when creating nonfiction biographies compared to fictional stories?

AP: There is definitely a lot more time spent on researching nonfiction picture book topics and finding the right voice and tone of the text so it doesn’t sound like an encyclopedia entry. The illustrations are just as important so that any biographical figure is portrayed accurately and consistently, no matter if the illustration style is more realistic or stylized. I always try to get some insight from the person directly or their family if the figure has passed away; even though an author can write a book about a public figure, I prefer to reach out and get approval first if possible.

RVC: Are there any things that are the same with fiction and nonfiction?

AP: I like to include back matter. All three of my fictional books that will be released in 2026 have back matter; I felt it was important to give a little more insight and information to the reader besides just the story. This also helps with sales to schools, libraries, and homeschool families. However, I do try to make sure there are similar aspects in all my books regardless of genre so my style is threading through all of them.

RVC: Your work often shines a spotlight on Latino figures and their contributions. What draws you to these stories, and how do you decide which ones to bring to life?

AP: My father was from the Dominican Republic, and I always connected to his side of the family very strongly, despite growing up in New Jersey and not learning Spanish until I was older. I also began working with children of migrant workers during a summer program and eventually became a bilingual /​ English as a Second Language teacher to help students learn English. It was in these roles where I was exposed to many other Latino cultures. Having also taught Spanish in elementary schools, many of my non-​Latino students were fascinated in learning Spanish and about Latino cultures, so I think these books are as much for them to learn about people and topics outside of their own culture as it is for Latino children to be seen and feel seen.

RVC: Let’s pivot to talk about art. Your illustration style is rich with texture and color. Can you share your favorite tools or techniques, and how your process has evolved over the years?

AP: I am a big fan of bold, colorful art and illustrations. One of my favorite children’s book illustrators is Eric Carle, so I also have painted acrylic on tissue paper to create collage pieces and also to scan and insert those painted papers digitally into illustrations. I used to try to draw more realistically but have been learning to loosen up and get more stylized. I tend to feel most comfortable having a pencil in my hand and getting my fingers dirty with pastels, watercolor, colored pencil and glue from collaging rather than a stylus to draw digitally.

In the past, I have drawn the illustration outlines with brown colored pencil, painted and colored the spreads by hand, scanned in everything, and then put it all together like a digital puzzle in Photoshop. However, since I’m working on two books at once right now, I will be coloring mostly everything in with a mix of Photoshop and Procreate to save time, including bringing in scanned textures to still maintain a hand-​illustrated look.

RVC: It’s always fascinating to me the lengths people go to make digital art look like hand-​created art. But you said it–it’s simply more efficient, right?

AP: It’s amazing to me what people are able to do with digital mediums these days, and I’m just getting started. The digital tools available to artists today definitely are helpful to save time, to keep colors and characters consistent, and to provide a wide range of brushes and textures to incorporate. However, in the end they are just tools; it’s really up to the creativity of the artist to make their art look good and unique, no matter if done by hand or digitally. I will say, though, that I think most publishers want final art in digital format whether that’s completely finished digital art or handmade art that is scanned in.

RVC: So, you’ve worked with literary organizations and educational publishers as a developmental editor and consultant. What does that collaborative process look like, and how do you ensure your work meets the needs of teachers and students?

AP: Most of my freelance work has been work-​for-​hire ESL, Spanish, or Literacy projects with specific specs to follow. I’ve sometimes been involved in the brainstorming and planning process of a program to make sure the skills and educational standards are being addressed in an effective scope-​and-​sequence. Other times, I’ve been a translator or the person to write or edit material. Other than working part time for an educational publisher in Miami where I would go into the office a few times a week, all of my freelance work has been done virtually via email. I’m usually working on updating previous editions of a textbook series, writing activity ideas for the teachers to implement in their classrooms, or starting on new projects that address the most current educational trends and state standards to ensure that the teachers have the necessary tools for maximizing standardized testing results.

logoRVC: As part of your work with Reading Partners, you wrote and art-​directed the Cover to Cover series, designed to support the science of reading. What was your approach to creating these decodable books, and what impact do you hope they have on young readers?

AP: With the Cover to Cover books, students learn to decode and read high-​frequency words throughout a story that only incorporates the phonics skills previously taught while also reading true sight words. In addition, the books address reading comprehension. The stories are geared toward a first-​grade level; however, the characters and story lines are mature enough that any elementary student in K‑5 can learn to read from them.

We first developed a scope and sequence that scaffolds phonics skills and sight words decided by evidence-​based research in the science of reading. Then I worked on the manuscripts (I’ve written about 90% of the stories so far). We made sure to have a diverse array characters and situations to keep readers’ interests high and make sure all students feel seen and are seen. We looked for authenticity readers in our organization to provide feedback. After editing, we worked with a hybrid publisher to secure illustrators. Then I switched hats from writing to art directing by reviewing character sketches, storyboards, final art, and layout. It’s been a great experience to not only learn how to write decodable texts but also to work on all aspects of the books from start to finish.

RVC: Wow, that’s a lot of hats. What’s so appealing about being an integral part in making these kinds of books (which are different from the types of books many kidlit writers dream of making when they first get into this field)?

AP: What I like best about these books is that they are full color, decodable books with really strong art and engaging texts. I believe they’re different than what’s on the decodable book market today. We wanted to make sure that kids at any age using the Reading Partners curriculum felt like they were reading books at the same quality as the ones they could find in a bookstore. At Reading Partners, we’re not only helping students to build their literary skills but also their love for reading.

RVC: I know you’re a fan of SCBWI—that’s how I first heard about you. What effect has this organization had on your career as a creative?

Paula Danziger: The Cat Ate My Gymsuit / There's a Bat in Bunk Five / Can You Sue Your Parents for MalpracticeAP: Yes! My first SCBWI conference was in Miami in 2004 where I heard Paula Danziger speak! I couldn’t believe I was in the same room with famous authors and illustrators. But that’s what’s so great about SCBWI. It’s an organization for the most well-​known to pre-​published book creators. We all belong and are made to feel like we fit in. Between attending conference workshops, paying for critiques, putting my portfolio out for viewing, mingling with other creators, and becoming part of my long-​time critique group, SCBWI has changed my life completely. I was a semi-​finalist in the Tomie dePaola illustration contest in 2014, and I won first place in the Florida SCBWI Rising Kite contest in 2014. I also won first place in the portfolio showcase at the 2023 Florida SCBWI conference.

RVC: Congrats on all of that success!

AP: Thanks! I signed with my agent after meeting her at a conference, and three out of my five books under contract are direct results of paid critiques from the conferences over the years. There are so many resources SCBWI offers and opportunities to learn and connect. I highly encourage anyone who wants to write literature for children to join SCBWI.

RVC: Say a few words about your experience with critique groups.

AP: I’ve been with my author critique group since 2004. We all met through SCBWI and started in person. When the pandemic hit in 2020, and some of us moved out of the area, we switched to just emailing each other our stories and meeting periodically in Zoom. Without their honest insight and feedback, there’s no way I would be published today. I emphasize the word “honest” because I need them to tell me what is really working and what really stinks. No sugar coating at this point!

RVC: Absolutely not!

AP: Also, for the last five years, I have also belonged to a critique group for illustrators, where I share my book dummies and character sketches. Their insight has also strengthened my submissions greatly because they’re looking at my work from not just a writer’s viewpoint but from an artist’s as well. The members of these groups are all more than my critique partners; they are truly my friends for life who have cheered me on and picked me up when I felt like giving up on getting published.

RVC: Let’s switch things up and focus on the audience. What key messages or feelings do you hope kids take away after reading your books?

AP: I want readers to make some kind of emotional connection to my books, whether they laugh at something I wrote or get that “aww” feeling. Even though many of my books’ characters and topics right now are from a Latino background, I think all readers, whether Latino or not, can find a way to relate to a character or situation to make a lasting connection with their own lives, experiences, and dreams. Most of all, I want them to just enjoy reading and revel in their imagination.

RVC: Working as an Editorial Assistant at Bushel & Peck Books gives you a front-​row seat to the manuscript journey, from submissions we pass on to those we acquire and shepherd through production. What kinds of AHA moments have you had from seeing this process unfold, and how has it influenced your own creative work?

AP: First, I want to thank you for the opportunity to work with you as your assistant at Bushel & Peck Books. I’m learning so much each week, and I appreciate the chance to be able to learn more about publishing through this work.

RVC: Happy to have you aboard!

AP: I love to review manuscripts and provide insight that will hopefully make the texts even stronger. One big AHA moment was attending the staff meeting where I heard everyone provide their opinions and insights when deciding if a particular manuscript was going to be acquired. It was so interesting hearing different perspectives, and knowing what a publisher may be looking for when making that tough decision made me stop and rethink the strengths and weaknesses of some of my own story ideas. Could they be publish-​worthy, or do they still need that special something that would make them stand out at an acquisitions meeting?

RVC: Last question for this part of the interview. What are some upcoming projects that you’re really excited about?

AP: I have four books releasing in 2026! Right now, I am working on the illustrations for two upcoming picture books, An Island Called Home (Eerdman’s, 2026) about a girl who visits her father’s island home for the first time (based on my life visiting my dad’s home in the Dominican Republic each summer), and Sisters All the Time (Charlesbridge, 2026) about two half-​sisters who have to figure out how to have fun before their visitation time is up, based on me having younger and older half-siblings.

My two other upcoming books I wrote but am not illustrating: Lucia’s Goals (Lee & Low) started off as nonfiction but got changed to fiction. It’s about a girl who at first plays soccer on a boys’ team until she’s able to try out for a local girls’ team. And the fourth book is From the Fields to the Fight about Jessica Govea Thorbourne who worked with Cesar Chavez during the Delano Grape Boycott and helped fight for labor union rights.

RVC: Thanks for that, Angela. Now it’s time to shift gears and enter the SPEED ROUND. Zoomy questions followed by zippy answers please. Are you ready to begin?

AP: As my 16-​year-​old son would say, “Let’s goooo!”

RVC: Star Wars, Star Trek, or Stargate?

AP: Star Wars.

RVC: What makes your eyes roll every time you hear it?

AP: Brah (aka Bro).

RVC: What’s your go-​to karaōke song? 

AP: “Eye of the Tiger” – karaōke, singing in the car or in the shower: anywhere anytime!

RVC: If you could illustrate any classic picture book, which one would you choose?

AP: The Story of Ferdinand by Munro Leaf.

RVC: What’s one word that best describes your creative process?

AP: Winding.

RVC: What’s the best compliment you’ve ever received from a young reader?

AP: “That’s cool!” If a child thinks you as an adult are cool, you’re winning.

RVC: Thanks so much, Angela!

Picture Book Review: Five-​Word Reviews (Guest Post: Lexi Hall)

This is the first time I’ve ever asked someone to do a five-​word review guest post, and I’m so excited to introduce Lexi Hall! She’s a children’s writer and illustrator living in Boston, where she works as the children’s bookseller at Beacon Hill Books & Café (imagine being surrounded by all those picture books!). She’s also pursuing her MFA in children’s book writing and illustration, and is even illustrating a forthcoming picture book, Enough Elizabeths.

I asked Lexi to find five new picture books that she digs, and I can’t wait to see what caught her eye. Let’s find out!


One Light
Author: Christie Matheson
Illustrator: Anuska Allepuz
Farrar, Straus and Giroux (BYR)

24 September 2024
40 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Timely. Powerful. One spark ignites. 

4.5 out of 5 lights in the darkness


Perfect
Author: Waka T. Brown
Illustrator: Yuko Jones
Quill Tree Books
1 October 2024
40 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Love-​mended treasures. Accepting flaws. Tender!

4.75 out of 5 kintsugi teacups


Pig Town Party
Author: Lian Cho
Illustrator: Lian Cho
HarperCollins
29 October 2024
40 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Mix-​up, costume contest, pig-​giggle fest!

4.25 out of 5 mud cakes


Sari Sisters
Author: Anitha Rao-​Robinson
Illustrator: Anoosha Syed
Viking Books for Young Readers
22 October 2024
32 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Sharing precious milestones, sisterly-​love story.

4.5 out of 5 sari dance parties!


The Verts
Author: Ann Patchett
Illustrator: Robin Preiss Glasser
HarperCollins
17 September 2024
40 pages

Lexi’s five-​word review: Crowded party? Solo-​celebration? Honoring differences.

4.25 out of 5 tinfoil stars


Lexi Hall is a children’s writer and illustrator from Pittsburgh PA. Growing up, she fell in love with writing and illustrating her own little stories to share with her friends. Now, she lives and works in Boston, MA as the children’s bookseller at Beacon Hill Books & Café, where she is spoiled with daily access to all the picture books she can read!

Lexi is pursuing her MFA in children’s book writing and illustration from Hollins University. She has illustrated for Hollins University Magazine and The Big Kit & Lil’ Kaboodle children’s magazine. She has also illustrated an upcoming 2025 picture book written by author Heather Harris Bergevin, Enough Elizabeths, with Lucky Rabbit Publishing.

Website: www.lexihall.com

Instagram: @lexi.paints

Picture Book List: 4 Picture Books that Kidlit Editors Often Mention—and Why They’re So Good

While classics like Where the Wild Things Are often get the spotlight, there are many other picture books that kidlit editors frequently recommend and reference for their unique qualities. These books simply have something special about them that makes them invaluable resources for teaching, reading, and sparking joy.

So, instead of doing my normal industry insider interview this week, I’m going to share four picture books that I hear kidlit editors talk about a lot. And I’m including a few of the main things those editors often say about these books.

**If OPB readers enjoy this kind of access into what editors are thinking/​saying, I’ll look into doing more of this from time to time. And perhaps I’ll share some of the picture book titles that I frequently talk about and recommend, too.**


Alma and How She Got Her Name by Juana Martinez-Neal

Why Editors Love It:

  • Cultural and Personal Identity: This book’s focus on a young girl discovering the stories behind her names creates a rich, relatable exploration of heritage. Editors often mention its power to foster pride in one’s background and spark discussions about personal identity in a natural way.
  • Illustrative Details: Martinez-Neal’s illustrations, created in soft, warm tones and detailed pencil, evoke a sense of intimacy and family warmth. The textures and gentle lines make each page feel personal and inviting.
  • Conversation Starter: The book naturally invites readers to think about their own names and the stories they carry, making it a great tool for classroom activities and family reading time.

The Bear and the Piano - Scholastic Kids' ClubThe Bear and the Piano by David Litchfield

Why Editors Love It:

  • A Story with Layers: Litchfield’s tale explores ambition, friendship, and the bittersweet nature of success. Editors find it compelling that the story can be appreciated on different levels, offering something new for readers as they grow older.
  • Visually Stunning: The illustrations are a blend of light, color, and texture, creating a sense of magic that captivates the eye. Litchfield’s art has an enchanting quality that complements the story’s emotional arc, making it a book editors often recommend for its artistic merit.
  • Emotional Range: The narrative carries readers through a journey of joy, loss, and fulfillment, demonstrating how picture books can touch on complex emotions in a way that feels genuine and relatable.

The Invisible String by Patrice Karst, illustrated by Joanne Lew-Vriethoff

Why Editors Love It:

  • Universal Emotional Appeal: This book addresses the concept of an unbreakable bond between loved ones, no matter how far apart they may be. Editors value how it introduces the idea of emotional resilience and comfort in an accessible way that resonates with children and adults alike.
  • Simple Yet Powerful Message: The story’s clear and heartfelt message about connection makes it a favorite for social-​emotional learning. Editors point out how The Invisible String is often used as a resource to help children navigate feelings of separation or loss.
  • Approachable Illustrations: Lew-Vriethoff’s art complements the story with warm, friendly illustrations that depict diverse characters, making the story relatable to a wide range of readers. The balance between text and illustration is seamless, enhancing the impact of the book’s comforting theme.

The Rabbit Listened by Cori Doerrfeld

Why Editors Love It:

  • Simple Yet Profound: The text is simple, but its impact is significant. The book teaches young readers the power of empathy and listening without offering solutions. Editors admire this as a masterclass in using simplicity to convey deep emotional truths.
  • Universally Relatable Theme: The book’s exploration of grief and the different ways people respond to loss resonates with readers of all ages. Editors often highlight how it encourages conversation between adults and children about emotional resilience and support.
  • Illustrations That Amplify the Message: Doerrfeld’s gentle, expressive illustrations subtly add to the story’s emotional weight without overpowering the text. The use of space and character expressions enhances the message of understanding and connection.

These four titles serve as excellent examples of how picture books can be simple yet profound, funny yet wise, and always impactful. Whether you’re revisiting these stories or discovering them for the first time, they remind us why well-​wrought picture books hold a special place in the hearts and minds of readers of all ages.

Reading Activities: Ronan the Librarian, by Tara Luebbe & Becky Cattie, illustrated by Victoria Maderna

RONAN THE LIBRARIAN

Ronan the Librarian
Author: Tara Luebbe & Becky Cattie
Illustrator: Victoria Maderna
21 April 2020
Roaring Brook Press
40 pages

Book description: “Ronan was a mighty barbarian.
He invaded. He raided. And back home, he traded.
He always found the greatest treasures.
Until one day, Conan found something no barbarian wants:
BOOK.

This humorous picture book from sister duo Tara Luebbe and Becky Cattie and illustrator Victoria Maderna follows Ronan the Barbarian as he he grows from being just a rough-​and-​tumble warrior to a rough-​and-​tumble warrior who loves books.

At first, his fellow barbarians are skeptical of his newfound passion for reading, but in the end, even they aren’t immune to the charms of a good book.


Reading Activities inspired by Ronan the Librarian:

  • Before Reading–From looking at the front cover: 
    • What do you think the book will be about based on the title, Ronan the Librarian?
    • Can you guess what kind of character Ronan is from the front cover? What clues do you see?
    • What do you think barbarians do? How do you imagine them acting?
    • Do you think a barbarian can also be a librarian? Why or why not?
    • Why do you think books might be important to Ronan?
    • What kind of adventures do you think Ronan might have with books?
    • What questions would you like to ask the author or the illustrator before reading the book?
  • After Reading–Now that you’ve read the story: 
    • What made Ronan change his mind about books?
    • How did Ronan’s friends react to his love of reading? Why do you think they felt that way?
    • How did the illustrations add to the story? Did you notice the book-​eating goat?
    • What do you think is the main message of the story?
    • What would you have done to convince the other barbarians to read?
    • How do you think Ronan felt at the end of the book when everyone started reading?
    • Would you recommend this book to a friend? What part would you tell them about first?
  • Create Your Own Library Sign: Design a library sign that Ronan might use. Think of fun phrases like “Come Read! Free Mead!” or make up your own! Use markers, crayons, or colored pencils to make it bright and inviting.
  • Build a Book Fort: Just like Ronan stacked his books all over, create your own book fort! Use books, blankets, and pillows to make a cozy space where you can read. Once it’s built, choose a book and enjoy reading in your special fort.
  • Draw Your Barbarian Character: Imagine you are a character in Ronan’s village. What would you look like as a barbarian? Draw yourself with armor, a wild boar companion, or other fun details. Don’t forget to add a favorite book under your arm!
  • Read-​Aloud Role Play: Pretend you’re Ronan reading a thrilling story to the other barbarians. Choose your favorite book or passage and practice reading it aloud with dramatic voices and expressions to make it exciting, just like Ronan did.
  • Write Your Own Barbarian Story: Imagine that you are a friend of Ronan’s who also discovers a love of books. Write a short story about what book you found and how it changed you. Did it lead to new adventures or ideas? Share your story with someone you know or read it aloud to your class or family.
  • Further Reading: If you loved Ronan the Librarian, you might also enjoy other books about libraries and the magic of books.

A sing-​song celebration of libraries, perfect for reading aloud. This story follows a young girl as she visits the library and discovers all the exciting things it holds, showcasing how libraries can be full of surprises.

 


This enchanting story tells of a little librarian and her three owl assistants who run a library that opens only at night. As they help all sorts of animals find the perfect books, the story celebrates the magic of libraries as places of adventure and wonder.


In this humorous and relatable tale, Miss Brooks, an enthusiastic librarian, tries to inspire a reluctant reader who insists she doesn’t like books. The story encourages readers to find their perfect book, showing that everyone has a story they’ll love.

 

 


A historical picture book that tells the true story of how Thomas Jefferson’s love for books led to the creation of the Library of Congress. This book shares Jefferson’s passion for reading and collecting books, and how it influenced one of the largest libraries in the world.

 


Based on a true story, this book follows a young girl named Ana who loves books but has limited access to them in her rural village. Her life changes when a traveling librarian arrives on a burro with books to share. This story showcases the power of books to transform lives and highlights the importance of access to literature.